Round 22 2023 Other (non-Manly) games discussion

So hip drops are sin bins now?? and after possession of the ball has changed??

That is a complete BS call from the bunker... complete BS

They've taken the game back to a previous set now... after possession has changed hands... does that mean they can just go back as far as they want?

They've binned him because he got his leg strapped... the NRL is a ****ing JOKE!!
 
So hip drops are sin bins now?? and after possession of the ball has changed??

That is a complete BS call from the bunker... complete BS

They've taken the game back to a previous set now... after possession has changed hands... does that mean they can just go back as far as they want?

They've binned him because he got his leg strapped... the NRL is a ****ing JOKE!!
Game management. Gotta keep it close and exciting. It's not even Subtle
 
Game management. Gotta keep it close and exciting. It's not even Subtle
Binning a player from the losing side is the opposite of that... unless game management is required to ensure a manly win.

My biggest issue was them going back to a previous set... I don't think I've ever seen that before... once possession changes hands they're usually only able to put a player on report and that's it.
 
They only went back and looked at that when figuring out why old mate was getting his knee strapped. They had no clue prior.

Then you take into account that its one of the weakest hip drops seen in recent weeks.
 
Binning a player from the losing side is the opposite of that... unless game management is required to ensure a manly win.

My biggest issue was them going back to a previous set... I don't think I've ever seen that before... once possession changes hands they're usually only able to put a player on report and that's it.

I've never seen them go back a set and penalise the team, whilst also binning someone.

The Bunker literally had two sets to look at it, but didn't deem it a binning... until old mate wanted to get some strapping put on it
In this case, yeah, but it sets precedent. (Not that they are consistent). The bunker only grows in power. It simply becomes an overwatching dictator.
 
In this case, yeah, but it sets precedent. (Not that they are consistent). The bunker only grows in power. It simply becomes an overwatching dictator.
Ridiculous how much power the bunker currently has... it's seriously going to **** someone over in the finals
 
Refs are even saying now "it's been reviewed. Nothing I can do about it". Gives the NRL all the power it wants to influence a game. As soon as the bunker says gone, there is no debate. Once upon a time, this would be handled with the MRC, now it is a double-whammy. Double jeopardy, like we saw with Arthars on Taafe.
 
Refs are even saying now "it's been reviewed. Nothing I can do about it". Gives the NRL all the power it wants to influence a game. As soon as the bunker says gone, there is no debate. Once upon a time, this would be handled with the MRC, now it is a double-whammy. Double jeopardy, like we saw with Arthars on Taafe.
Unless you're Tedesco who's powers are stronger than the bunkers review and gets them to go back and look again
 
Unless you're Tedesco who's powers are stronger than the bunkers review and gets them to go back and look again
That review on Kotoni knocking the ball back in was so strange. I thought Cobbo knocked it back, Staggs toed it forward, ball goes dead and then he tried to tap it back in. Ref seemed to say it went dead off Roosters, then Kotoni tried to flick it back in. But it was always out by Brisbane the way I saw it.
 
That review on Kotoni knocking the ball back in was so strange. I thought Cobbo knocked it back, Staggs toed it forward, ball goes dead and then he tried to tap it back in. Ref seemed to say it went dead off Roosters, then Kotoni tried to flick it back in. But it was always out by Brisbane the way I saw it.
Oh they got the call right in the end, it was just funny that bunker reviewed it, said it was a drop out, then only when Tedesco whinged they checked again and got the the right call. Incompetence really is the only way to describe it.
 
Let's gone Sharkies... somehow

prayer GIF
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
Back
Top Bottom