Cross-Forum-Discussion Round 11 2023 Cross Forum Chat

[NZWarriors.com]

	Mr Frank White - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 19, 2012 MESSAGES: 5,257 REACTIONS: 11,383

---

	Big Pete - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .March 11, 2008 MESSAGES: 30,416 Reaction Score: 21,000

---

So the automic sin-bin for a hip drop is dead.

Thank god, but Carrigan shouldn't have been made a matyr.

---

There’s way worse examples than Carrigan lol. Carrigans was lazy and penalty only. That there wasn’t event that.

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Big Pete - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .March 11, 2008 MESSAGES: 30,417 Reaction Score: 21,001

---

	Mr Frank White - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 19, 2012 MESSAGES: 5,257 REACTIONS: 11,383

---

There’s way worse examples than Carrigan lol. Carrigans was lazy and penalty only. That there wasn’t event that.

---

Yet they only came to their senses seemingly after the Carrigan incident.

It wasn't a penalty either. Watch Annesley's debrief and focus on the part about trapping the lower body with your full body weight. Now watch Carrigan's and tell me where his hip ends up. It was never a penalty, it was a stictch up.

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Bull Shark - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .June 4, 2008 MESSAGES: 5,605 Reaction Score: 4,433

---

Me and the NRL if they have indeed scrapped the auto sin bin for anything & everything resembling a hip drop tackle..

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Brocko - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .February 23, 2014 MESSAGES: 1,655 Reaction Score: 2,948

---

That's class from Starling

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Brocko - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .February 23, 2014 MESSAGES: 1,656 Reaction Score: 2,948

---

Me and the NRL if they have indeed scrapped the auto sin bin for anything & everything resembling a hip drop tackle.. View attachment 22236

I'll wait until we see it benefit majority of teams, not just Parra and Cows

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Sproj - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .September 5, 2013 MESSAGES: 43,032 Reaction Score: 49,568

---

Just switched over as Lions are on half time, I didn't know Kris had such quick acceleration.

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Brocko - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .February 23, 2014 MESSAGES: 1,657 Reaction Score: 2,948

---

Gutho was sold the decoy beautifully and was well out of position to try and stop that try

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	BroncosFever - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .June 6, 2014 MESSAGES: 4,020 Reaction Score: 7,461

---

So the automic sin-bin for a hip drop is dead.

Thank god, but Carrigan shouldn't have been made a matyr.

He may be the only player in the history of the NRL to be made the example of in both the beginning and ending of a crackdown.

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Sproj - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .September 5, 2013 MESSAGES: 43,033 Reaction Score: 49,569

---

Me and the NRL if they have indeed scrapped the auto sin bin for anything & everything resembling a hip drop tackle.. View attachment 22236

If the NRL:
1. Got rid of Vlandys and Abdo
2. Got rid of six agains
3. Got rid of these ridiculous crackdowns
4. Got rid of Annersley
5. Made the bunker rule ONLY on tries and captain's challenges and all their communications with refs must be made open to all
6. Completely overhauled the MRC with people trained unconnected to any league team, even league itself
7. Stopped rewarding diving
8. Actually refereed fairly
9. Got rid of gambling connections
10. Rewarded clubs who develop talent far more


Then I would likely be back on good terms with this sport

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Sproj - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .September 5, 2013 MESSAGES: 43,034 Reaction Score: 49,569

---

And I feel like I say this every week but surely whoever was responsible for losing Mahoney and replacing him with Hodgson has been sacked right?

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Bull Shark - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .June 4, 2008 MESSAGES: 5,606 Reaction Score: 4,434

---

I'll wait until we see it benefit majority of teams. Could just be a who's playing type deal yet

Geez I pray it’s a universal change.. the over use of the sin bin is a scourge on Rugby League, no matter who is playing

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Bull Shark - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .June 4, 2008 MESSAGES: 5,607 Reaction Score: 4,434

---

If the NRL:
1. Got rid of Vlandys and Abdo
2. Got rid of six agains
3. Got rid of these ridiculous crackdowns
4. Got rid of Annersley
5. Made the bunker rule ONLY on tries and captain's challenges and all their communications with refs must be made open to all
6. Completely overhauled the MRC with people trained unconnected to any league team, even league itself
7. Stopped rewarding diving
8. Actually refereed fairly
9. Got rid of gambling connections
10. Rewarded clubs who develop talent far more


Then I would likely be back on good terms with this sport

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	BroncosFever - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .June 6, 2014 MESSAGES: 4,021 Reaction Score: 7,463

---

And I feel like I say this every week but surely whoever was responsible for losing Mahoney and replacing him with Hodgson has been sacked right?

It's a weird signing because when Hodgson was playing incredibly well at Canberra, he had to be playing that well given how much control he demanded from dummy half, at Parra they've got one of the elite halves combinations, his job should be to feed them the ball and chime in occasionally himself.

I haven't seen him getting that balance right though.

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Brocko - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .February 23, 2014 MESSAGES: 1,658 Reaction Score: 2,948

---

Did Hodgson get injured and need surgery after Eels had already signed him?

He really hasn't come back from injury anywhere near the standard he was at for Raiders

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Brocko - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .February 23, 2014 MESSAGES: 1,659 Reaction Score: 2,948

---

Another penalty won by milking for an 'escort'.

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Super Freak - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .January 25, 2014 MESSAGES: 36,448 Reaction Score: 24,023

---

Sweet 3 from 3 tonight.

2 more to go.

---

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Organix - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .September 19, 2012 MESSAGES: 4,168 Reaction Score: 5,103

---

As for Paix's try.

Marker is giving just as much as what Flegler was giving. Play on.

That's how i saw it too, and obviously the refs.

---

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Aman - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .April 9, 2016 MESSAGES: 5,998 REACTIONS: 13,398

---

	BroncosFever - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .June 6, 2014 MESSAGES: 4,020 Reaction Score: 7,461

---

He may be the only player in the history of the NRL to be made the example of in both the beginning and ending of a crackdown.

---

Umm Marata Nuikora being pulled up 5 plays after the incident was what started this whole thing.

---

 

[The Who]

	Sproj - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .September 5, 2013 MESSAGES: 43,033 Reaction Score: 49,569

---

If the NRL:

5. Made the bunker rule ONLY on tries and captain's challenges and all their communications with refs must be made open to all

---

The Bunker can't rule on forward passes; nor can it rule on anything other than the final play leading to a 'try'. It could see a howler in an earlier play and still have to award a try. The rules governing the Bunker are flawed; not to mention that the Vidiot in the Bunker makes more mistakes than Aloiai.

 

[BroncosHQ.com]

	Fernando - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .June 5, 2015 MESSAGES: 3,153 Reaction Score: 3,217

---

The automatic sinbin for a hip drop clearly ended when Annesley came out after the Broncos/Storm game and said if there's any doubt it should be placed on report only (that said Carrigan's hip drop last year was a bad one and is one of the very few that should be eliminated)

---