RLW Player Ratings Man v New

[RL Gronk]

I thought Symonds was better than a 4/10.
I would of scored him atleast 6 probably more

 

[Berkeley_Eagle]

And Matai still got a 7 for 20min

 

[Dan]

Cant see how Symonds gets only half a game, takes 6 hitups, 2 offloads anda try assist and only gets 4

He had as much impact as Matai did. Anyway must be a hard marker is all

 

[Central Coast Eagle]

Didn't Matai play almost 40 minutes???

 

[Dan]

Didn't Matai play almost 40 minutes???

I thought he played most of the half as well

 

[manlyfan76]

Matai got injured at 37:45
Tom played 41 mins and stats as Daniel said for a 4 rating
Mason 19 mins for a 4 rating. 5 runs. How's that work?

 

[Shoe1]

Look no further than Gower v Symonds - you can see the reviewer just phoned it in with no thought - he or she gave both of them a 4. Similar hit-up and tackle stats for both. Symonds a try assist + 2 offloads vs Gower's 2 handling errors.

---

Is there an appeals process outlined in the fine print of RLW?

 

[MissKate]

those ratings are all over the shop, looks more like a popularity contest than genuine ratings for effort

 

[EagleFromMay1967]

They cant even get the facts. Brett Stewart for example,
I have him for at least 3 offloads and 2 try assists. RLW have 0 - 0.

 

[MadMarcus]

I thought the ratings were pretty much on the money except Symonds.

Matai deserved a 7 even though he played half the game IMO.

 

[mozgrame]

They cant even get the facts. Brett Stewart for example,
I have him for at least 3 offloads and 2 try assists. RLW have 0 - 0.

Maybe c eagle did his review. lol That was a joke c eagle, I mean no harm.😉