"Ridiculous Decision"- Brandy on Forans No Try

StuBoot said:
Interesting that CH 9 commentators thought the right call was made whereas Brandy & Co thought it was a try.

No, I'm sure that's not the case. I watched it on replay and all the Channel Nine commentators just accepted it as a try and were surprised that it went to video ref.

Why it went upstairs is the concern to me. It was an obvious try. So much so that the decision shocked Warriors fans at the ground.

Imagine if that decision had cost a grand final? Do we really need a video ref? They make so many bad calls that I'm all for the on field refs making an on-the-spot decision based on normal speed and gut instinct. Sure they'll get some wrong, but no more than the video refs do.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

  • Jethro
    Star Trekkin' across the universe

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 23 19 0 4 186 44
2 Storm 23 17 0 6 228 40
3 Bulldogs 23 16 0 7 138 38
4 Broncos 23 14 0 9 156 34
5 Warriors 23 14 0 9 22 34
6 Sharks 22 13 0 9 67 32
7 Panthers 23 12 1 10 87 31
8 Roosters 23 12 0 11 102 30
9 Sea Eagles 23 11 0 12 20 28
10 Dolphins 22 10 0 12 81 26
11 Tigers 23 9 0 14 -127 24
12 Eels 23 9 0 14 -132 24
13 Rabbitohs 23 9 0 14 -151 24
14 Cowboys 24 9 1 14 -146 23
15 Dragons 23 8 0 15 -110 22
16 Knights 22 6 0 16 -220 18
17 Titans 22 5 0 17 -201 16
Back
Top Bottom