OK I gotta go but you guys pretty much nailed it.
Here's a list I came up with, hopefully correct.
Asterisk means - not all while playing for Manly
Bold type - Manly only!!
Nate Myles 31*
Dale Shearer 26*
Fatty has 22
Martin Bella 21*
Steve Menzies 20*
DCE 20
Michael O’Connor 19*
Geoff Toovey 16*
Anthony Watmough 16
Jake Trbojevic 15
Aaron Woods 14*
Ben Kennedy 13*
Willie Mason 13*
(I gave Beaver and Tooves bold type as well as the asterisk because in their case the asterisk is stupid, because it wasn't their fault the club joined with Norths!)