Player Ratings v Storm

[The Royal Soup]

1 Tom Trbojevic - 2/10 not good enough, didnt look interested

2 Jason Saab - 6/10 tried hard, few errors

3 Brad Parker - 3/10 offered zero

4 Morgan Harper - ….. 0/10 dog ****

5 Reuben Garrick - 7/10 our best

6 Kieran Foran - 2/10 needed to take over and didn’t

7 Daly Cherry-Evans (c) - 1/10 that is not a captains performance, terrible last tackle options and terrible defence

8 Josh Aloiai - 5/10 wasn’t on long enough

15 Karl Lawton - 6/10 did nothing wrong but was gassed

10 Martin Taupau - 2/10 errors and not much more

11 Haumole Olakau’atu - 0/10 out of depth and lost the plot

12 Josh Schuster - 1/10 see above

13 Jake Trbojevic - 7/10 tried hard as always

Interchange

14 Dylan Walker - 7/10 great game, got hit high and we still haven’t seen a replay

20 Curtis Sironen - 1/10 why is he still
In this side?

16 Sean Keppie - 3/10 came on late did nothing wrong

17 Taniela Paseka - 3/10 again not on long enough

 

[Dion Johnson]

Looks close to what I watched, though I dont think Garrick was a 7, a 5 at best for me.

Keppie and Tent were the best of the big men..

 

[rmd]

Well that indicates you are clearly upset about how manly played Strone.

They were strangled by Melbourne and was like watching boys play against men.

The good news is there is always next year but I don’t think it will be until 2023

 

[Mal Cochrane]

Olakau’atu wasnt that bad

 

[The Royal Soup]

Olakau’atu wasnt that bad

He was completely caught up in the moment

 

[Dinga7]

Molly 0/10 give yourself and upper cut

 

[George Rose's Butcher]

Losing croker was big for us he has been there all season. Meanwhile they have two of the best in the game.

Turbo didn't get involved enough tonight we barely ran the normal plays we use. Foran did need to take over but didnt get a chance as we kept dropping it.

At least we have next week

 

[Mal Cochrane]

however you think he played, he was better than schuster and Tom. Be nice and give him a 5

 

[EagleFromMay1967]

Garrick 0
DCE -1
Harper -2
Shuster -3

 

[Chunkytuna]

Garrick 0
DCE -1
Harper -2
Shuster -3

Garrick less than Harper??? I presume you’re having a laugh.

 

[The Who]

What did Sandwich do wrong?
Harpo had a shocker, and The Shoe has been nobbled by his defensive role. It won't happen but he should be selected at 5/8 next week in the hope that he recaptures his attacking brilliance.

 

[frank stokes]

1 Tom Trbojevic - 2/10 not good enough, didnt look interested

2 Jason Saab - 6/10 tried hard, few errors

3 Brad Parker - 3/10 offered zero

4 Morgan Harper - ….. 0/10 dog ****

5 Reuben Garrick - 7/10 our best

6 Kieran Foran - 2/10 needed to take over and didn’t

7 Daly Cherry-Evans (c) - 1/10 that is not a captains performance, terrible last tackle options and terrible defence

8 Josh Aloiai - 5/10 wasn’t on long enough

15 Karl Lawton - 6/10 did nothing wrong but was gassed

10 Martin Taupau - 2/10 errors and not much more

11 Haumole Olakau’atu - 0/10 out of depth and lost the plot

12 Josh Schuster - 1/10 see above

13 Jake Trbojevic - 7/10 tried hard as always

Interchange

14 Dylan Walker - 7/10 great game, got hit high and we still haven’t seen a replay

20 Curtis Sironen - 1/10 why is he still
In this side?

16 Sean Keppie - 3/10 came on late did nothing wrong

17 Taniela Paseka - 3/10 again not on long enough

You know what @strone33... I reckon you nailed them....

 

[joeboy]

Tom and cherry were the big disappointments for mine, I can forgive Tom after he put us in this position to begin with.

Cherry is a fine player but never does much to dispel the flat track bully status he has. Foran was also largely invisible

Younger players will come good I hope but I do worry that our centres just don’t have enough in the their games

I’m not sure if we are using schuster right and I’d he has the wherewithal to impose himself in a game enough, he is playing within himself

Jake has plateaued as well

 

[The Royal Soup]

You know what @strone33... I reckon you nailed them....

Thanks mate

 

[malroon]

Can't go forward if the forwards are going backward..!

 

[BOZO]

1 Tom Trbojevic - 2/10 not good enough, didnt look interested

2 Jason Saab - 6/10 tried hard, few errors

3 Brad Parker - 3/10 offered zero

4 Morgan Harper - ….. 0/10 dog ****

5 Reuben Garrick - 7/10 our best

6 Kieran Foran - 2/10 needed to take over and didn’t

7 Daly Cherry-Evans (c) - 1/10 that is not a captains performance, terrible last tackle options and terrible defence

8 Josh Aloiai - 5/10 wasn’t on long enough

15 Karl Lawton - 6/10 did nothing wrong but was gassed

10 Martin Taupau - 2/10 errors and not much more

11 Haumole Olakau’atu - 0/10 out of depth and lost the plot

12 Josh Schuster - 1/10 see above

13 Jake Trbojevic - 7/10 tried hard as always

Interchange

14 Dylan Walker - 7/10 great game, got hit high and we still haven’t seen a replay

20 Curtis Sironen - 1/10 why is he still
In this side?

16 Sean Keppie - 3/10 came on late did nothing wrong

17 Taniela Paseka - 3/10 again not on long enough

Thats what forums are for feathered friend . Good to see your perspective and I agree with most of your ratings

 

[maxta]

Can't really rate that performance as anything but a 3 overall
That is the the team....what ppl don't understand is the poor performance of 1-2 players can change a game completely
Manly are still alive and fans need to still believe