NYEagle
Bencher
There were just 7 players of first grade standard in this squad of 17 tonight. How can Manly possibly win another game this year other than perhaps Newcastle at home. This is why I'd keep Barrett.
I felt sorry for Jake T, Buhrer, Parcell and Vave tonight. They absolutely busted their guts, but without first grade standard work around them they are just neutralised out of it doing all the work. Taupau went missing as usual, Taufua is wasted on the wing, and Tom T was hampered as well.
Manly need a new squad, and before next year. Please clear out all the players under the NSW Cup standard line except for Godinet and Knight.
First grade standard:
Tom Trbojevic - champion
Matt Parcell - a great find
Martin Taupau - impact player, but goes missing
Jamie Buhrer - champion
Jake Trbojevic - champion
Jorge Taufua - time for the forwards
Siosaia Vave - Georgie Rose
NSW cup standard:
Brett Stewart - finished. Burned out.
Lewis Brown - arm grabbing, lightweight garbage.
Brayden Wiliame - lighweight who is horrible in defense.
Pita Godinet - keep him for later. A spark
Apisai Koroisau - rubbish. I'm sorry, he's rubbish.
Darcy Lussick - tries hard but is slow slow slow.
Josh Starling - tries hard but is slow slow slow.
Matthew Wright - lighweight whois horrible in defense.
Blake Leary - tries hard good energy but not first grade standard
Liam Knight - keep him for later, lets see
With finals over, time to start planning for 2017.
NYEagle
I felt sorry for Jake T, Buhrer, Parcell and Vave tonight. They absolutely busted their guts, but without first grade standard work around them they are just neutralised out of it doing all the work. Taupau went missing as usual, Taufua is wasted on the wing, and Tom T was hampered as well.
Manly need a new squad, and before next year. Please clear out all the players under the NSW Cup standard line except for Godinet and Knight.
First grade standard:
Tom Trbojevic - champion
Matt Parcell - a great find
Martin Taupau - impact player, but goes missing
Jamie Buhrer - champion
Jake Trbojevic - champion
Jorge Taufua - time for the forwards
Siosaia Vave - Georgie Rose
NSW cup standard:
Brett Stewart - finished. Burned out.
Lewis Brown - arm grabbing, lightweight garbage.
Brayden Wiliame - lighweight who is horrible in defense.
Pita Godinet - keep him for later. A spark
Apisai Koroisau - rubbish. I'm sorry, he's rubbish.
Darcy Lussick - tries hard but is slow slow slow.
Josh Starling - tries hard but is slow slow slow.
Matthew Wright - lighweight whois horrible in defense.
Blake Leary - tries hard good energy but not first grade standard
Liam Knight - keep him for later, lets see
With finals over, time to start planning for 2017.
NYEagle