NSW Cup 2025

Wow, these young guys are seriously slick. Walsh and Zaidas are combining beautifully in Cup today — both are absolute musts for first grade next year. If you’re keen, I’d encourage you to check out the highlights on the BarTV website. They post 1-minute clips after each try, showing the full lead-up, which gives a much better feel for how certain blokes play compared to the usual short highlight reels.

Also, keep an eye on Ezekiel Paulo in jersey 19. He’s just come off the bench and looks really impressive for an 18/19-year-old who was still playing SG Ball earlier this year. He’s another one who’s stepped up through Ball, then Flegg, and now Reserve Grade this season, alongside Laiafi, Walsh, Zaidas, Hart, and Munn.

It’s a really promising core of young players coming through at Manly. Now we just have to hope Seibold has the balls and brains to start picking them.
Just hope that Uncle Nick or Uncle Gus aren't getting their cheque books ready...lol
 
Manly have handed the finals bound Jets a fourth straight loss, after showing up on a mission to end the year with some new additions to the highlight reel.

It was a poor start for manly, who came up with errors in their first 2 sets. Before long, Newtown capitalised on the field position. Niwhai Puru put a grubber through with a bit of pepper on it, and while Blake Metcalfe was trying to shield it over the dead ball line, Chris Vea’ila rocketed through to pounce on the ball before it could do so.

It was a good start from the Jets, but they were unable to build off of an early try when Jordin Leiu knocked it on in the set that followed. This opened the door for Manly to level scores, and they did so when young gun Joey Walsh snapped three defenders to cross the line.

Manly were looking to score from absolutely anywhere, but their next try was a gift from Dylan Coutts, who threw an intercept to the quickest man on the park, Navren Willett, who raced away to score the try, and with the conversion took Manly up by 6.

Their free flowing attack saw them double down to claim another try in the following set. Walsh, Metcalfe, and Zaidas Muagututia combined for a massive break when they exchanged a few crafty offloads. Walsh was pulled up just short of the line but Muagututia scooted out of dummy half to make it back to back tries for the Sea Eagles.

This filled them with confidence, and they continued to shift the ball around. Whilst trying to swing it from left to right well inside their own half, Sam Stonestreet picked off a pass from Brandon Wakeham to close the margin.

Manly didn’t let this discourage their adventurous attack however, and right on the stroke of halftime, a break from Ezekiel Paulo led to Muagututia scoring his second of the day when Walsh sent him over with a beautiful inside ball.

The Jets lost Niwhai Puru early into the second half, but they came out with plenty of intent, and after Pickering forced a dropout with a well placed grubber, he crossed for the first points of the half when Rajab put him through the manly defence with a great short ball.

Rajab continued stepping up in the absence of Niwhai Puru when he muscled his way over to reclaim the lead for Newtown. He over played his hand when they had their next attacking chance however, when his cutout pass hit the deck and was scooped up by Jordan Swann. Swann found Walsh inside him to work it near halfway.Stonestreet then put down a towering bomb, which was scooped up by Hugo Hart, who powered his way over the line to reclaim the lead.

This try was followed up shortly after when a double pump from Walsh led to Willett making a 50 metre break. Back in the Jets’ red zone, the Sea Eagles shifted it to the left where Semisi Kioa broke a tackle and cut inside to score a dazzling try.

The Jets went close to scoring again, but a forward pass from Michael Gabrael gave the ball back to Manly. As they were working out of their own end, Muagututia had another big impact on the game when he produced a lovely shortball for Jacob Sykes, who broke through the line and found Hart outside him to finish the job, putting the Maroon and Whites a little too far out of reach for Newtown.

The Jets showed plenty of fight when they won a short kick off in spectacular fashion, which led to a late try scored by Felix Faatili, but it was too little too late. Manly were able to put the cherry on top of their victory when Walsh danced around the defence once more to score another great try in the final moments of the match.

Fulltime: 42-30

Talking Points:

  • Joey Walsh put in another stellar performance to lead his side to victory this afternoon. He scored two brilliant individual tries off the back of his footwork, set up another, and was constantly finding gaps in Newtown’s defence to send his teammates through. He’s a real player of the future.
  • Zaidas Muagututia was another contender for best on ground today, picking up a double in the first half, and instigating Hugo Hart’s second try by putting Jacob Sykes through a gap. He was a massive contributor to most of Manly’s second phase play, and completely changed the game after getting onto the field.
  • The Newtown Jets are experiencing a form slump at the worst possible time of the season. They’ll have to pick themselves up by the bootstraps to turn things around in their elimination final against the Canberra Raiders next week, which may be difficult without gun halfback Niwhai Puru, who was taken from the field this afternoon.

Key Moment:

Zaidas Muagututia’s first try marked the moment that Manly really claimed dominance in this match. Just moments after Navren Willett’s intercept, the brilliant team break made by Walsh, Muagututia and Metcalfe saw them roll down the field with ease, leading to back to back tries.
 
Thanks for the tip! I found them here for anyone interested:


The team is packed full of youngsters. Really exciting actually.
Yeah, the team's form really picked up when the old blokes got bumped into the NRL team and the young guys (Walsh especially) came in. Great to see.
 
Kioa
1 try
19 runs 185 meters
62 post contact
1 line break
5 tackle breaks
10 tackle 2 miss
1 error

Walsh
2 tries
19 runs 187 meters (most by both teams)
65 post contact
2 line breaks
2 line break assists
1 try assist
10 tackle breaks
1 offload
14 tackle 4 miss
0 errors

Laiafi
57 minutes
12 runs 122 meters
51 post contact
7 tackle breaks
20 tackles 0 miss but 4 ineffective

Hart
60 mins
2 tries
8 runs 58 meters
11 post contact
1 line break assists
2 tackle breaks
24 tackles 2 miss

Patolo
35 mins
6 runs 88 meters
33 post contact
1 offload
21 tackle 0 miss 1 ineffective

Mafoa
23 mins
4 runs 41 meters
21 post contact
1 tackle break
11 tackles 0 miss 0 ineffective

Muagututia
27 mins
2 tries
5 runs 44 meters
3 line breaks
1 line break assist
4 tackle breaks
7 tackles 1 ineffective
 
Walsh is absolutely beating down the door.
What I liked most about the highlights was how pissed off with himself he looked when he missed a tackle on a rampaging second rower close to the line. The defensive line was a shambles, so he didn't really have much hope of making the tackle, but figured it's a good sign that he expected to make it and was disappointed when he didn't.
 
I thought Muagututia was a hooker but the match report described him as a utility. Can he play elsewhere?
He was an inpressive dummy half we got from Dogs and I feel in the modern game could 100% excel at a few positions....exceptional with acceleration and reminds me a lot of the "Fainu that could have been"
Personally feel he could be that player yet to play top grade, who will make a Massive impact as early as 2026, but you never know till the time comes.
 
Thanks for the tip! I found them here for anyone interested:


The team is packed full of youngsters. Really exciting actually.
I wonder what coach / coaching staff Silvertails can blame for developing and selecting all these youngsters who have gone ok in Ressies this year.

Why would Manly even do such a Silly thing? If one believed Seibold is adverse to blooding a young bloke in firsts?
 
I wonder what coach / coaching staff Silvertails can blame for developing and selecting all these youngsters who have gone ok in Ressies this year.

Why would Manly even do such a Silly thing? If one believed Seibold is adverse to blooding a young bloke in firsts?
Seibold has not given a player his debut all season. Some clubs had given eight debuts (and I'm not including Penrith's mob last match).
 
I wonder what coach / coaching staff Silvertails can blame for developing and selecting all these youngsters who have gone ok in Ressies this year.

Why would Manly even do such a Silly thing? If one believed Seibold is adverse to blooding a young bloke in firsts?
I must admit the young guys are looking good. The fact they are playing so well in Cup against men is a very good sign. If this was Toyota Cup I'd be much less enthused. If we can add a decent forward or two and bring in a few of these guys perhaps things are better than they appear.
 
Seibold has not given a player his debut all season. Some clubs had given eight debuts (and I'm not including Penrith's mob last match).
Yeah hopefully our club has more young ones ready to go next year.

I'm probably more critical of Seibs not having given Navale specifically more first grade in 25.

A couple of months back Navale seemed to be our one and only shinning light in Ressies. He has had a great year.

This group of youngsters, have had a good month and perhaps showing the benefit of being blooded early in Ressies.

But you would have to think Seibs has some influence in our NSW cup team developing all this young talent, which firsts currently lack.

A pre season under their belt and a one or two will be ready next year.

I do think it's easier for back and halves to debut then a forward, body size matters, but as always if they are good enough.
 
Seibold has not given a player his debut all season. Some clubs had given eight debuts (and I'm not including Penrith's mob last match).
To play devils advocate, you need to have the youngsters to debut.

Some of our youngsters like Walsh, Laifai, Zaidas and Hart are really coming on strong this last month but who do you feel has been the lay down misere first grader who should have debuted by now and hasnt?
 
Interesting debate here are the players (you can add Walsh now) that have made their debut during Seibold coaching career. There are some decent players in that lot. How hard were some of these players knoocking down the door ala Walsh? That said in 2019/20 the Broncos had the youngsters to debut.

Seibold DebutsAgeYear
Bullemor202020
Carrigan212019
Coates182019
Deardon182019
Farnworth202019
Flegler202019
Niu182020
Paix202020
Doueihi202018
Hiroti192018
Tatola222018
GCKT212024
Faulalo242024
Hopoate192024
Navale212024
Sam Fainu192023
Matterson262023
Humphreys222024

 
Interesting debate here are the players (you can add Walsh now) that have made their debut during Seibold coaching career. There are some decent players in that lot. How hard were some of these players knoocking down the door ala Walsh? That said in 2019/20 the Broncos had the youngsters to debut.

Seibold DebutsAgeYear
Bullemor202020
Carrigan212019
Coates182019
Deardon182019
Farnworth202019
Flegler202019
Niu182020
Paix202020
Doueihi202018
Hiroti192018
Tatola222018
GCKT212024
Faulalo242024
Hopoate192024
Navale212024
Sam Fainu192023
Matterson262023
Humphreys222024

Personally,I don’t give credit to the head coach for a players debut.Not really sure how much input they had in their development.What they do with the player after their first match is the biggest indicator on whether a coach can develop youngsters
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 23 19 0 4 186 44
2 Storm 23 17 0 6 228 40
3 Bulldogs 23 16 0 7 138 38
4 Broncos 23 14 0 9 156 34
5 Sharks 23 14 0 9 91 34
6 Warriors 23 14 0 9 22 34
7 Panthers 23 12 1 10 87 31
8 Roosters 23 12 0 11 102 30
9 Dolphins 23 11 0 12 87 28
10 Sea Eagles 23 11 0 12 20 28
11 Tigers 23 9 0 14 -127 24
12 Eels 23 9 0 14 -132 24
13 Rabbitohs 23 9 0 14 -151 24
14 Cowboys 24 9 1 14 -146 23
15 Dragons 23 8 0 15 -110 22
16 Knights 23 6 0 17 -244 18
17 Titans 23 5 0 18 -207 16
Back
Top Bottom