1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

My theory on why Manly isn't anyone's "second" team

Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by MadMarcus, Sep 29, 2011.

  1. MadMarcus

    MadMarcus Local Lunatic 2017 Tipping Competitor

    +8,380 /74
    I read in one News Ltd article something along the lines of "How many people have Manly as their "second" team? None."

    This was cited as proof positive that we are hated, but if you stop to think about it, there is actually a completely logical explanation why Manly isn't anyone's "second" team.

    If you have a "second" team, it is probably because your own team is so sh!t that most Septembers you have nobody to support. It follows that you would gravitate towards a team that is most similar to your own (ie. also sh!t), which would of course rule Manly out.

    My logic also explains why Manly fans don't usually have "second" teams. As our team is always there to support, we don't need one.
  2. manlysister

    manlysister Member

    +18 /0
    I never understood that second team bit. There is ever only ONE team I would support & that is the MIGHTY MANLY SEA EAGLES.
  3. The Who

    The Who Well-Known Member Premium Member

    +7,250 /173
    Many supporter's 'second team' was Norths because they were so inoffensive and loveable in their ineptitude. They were my second team, simply because I lived most of my life in their area.

    Now I think Cronulla gets the sympathy vote. How can anyone not feel sorry for a perennial loser?
  4. angryassdrummer

    angryassdrummer Member

    +5 /0
    manly was my 2nd team for the last few years
    long story short
    grew up in newcastle as a kid loving the doggies
    then in 88 when i was 11 the knights came in
    so i liked both of them equally
    met my partner who is from manly and very very passionate about the sea eagles
    so to make it more fun they were my 2nd team, knights.doggies first
    however i became disenchanted with doggies with all the yobbos etc
    it wasnt like that growing up
    also, moved from newcastle to byron bay in 1990 so felt knights werent my team anymore...
    so slowly over the last few years i followed manly more and more
    till in 2009 i accepted they were my main team and knights/doggies 2nd
    wasnt cause they were winning, they werent and i really didnt like orford at all i remember saying when he goes i will like manly more
    so... became a manly fan through and through
    i know most of you loved them since childhood but im upfront i didnt but love them as much as anyone now and will continue to do so
  5. Volley

    Volley Well-Known Member

    +1,109 /54
    That last sentence is very debatable.

  6. Peter C

    Peter C Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

    +1,207 /26
    I agree Manly or nothing, we are hated by everyone who isn't a Manly supporter because this hatred is passed on from father to son, the same as political persuasion is passed down.
    If you ask a Manly hater why they hate Manly, the reasons are.
    1. We buy all the good players, that's B.S. when you consider we have probably produced more local products that went on to represent than any other club. Most of those haters wouldn't even know who Branigan and O'neil , or Dorahy and Boyd are.
    2. There was a perception of favouritism in the Ken Arthurson era, when in reality because of KA and a loyalty to the ARL during the Super League days, we had to fund our own battle for the ARL, something from which we have never recovered from.
    3 We killed off the Bears, when in reality they killed themselves, enough said.
    You cannot reason with idiots, especially idiots who support another team
  7. ads

    ads Well-Known Member

    +29 /1
    Hey - some of us are born true supporters and some of us see the light a bit later. Either way you are now supporting the best team in the comp - so that's great news.
  8. angryassdrummer

    angryassdrummer Member

    +5 /0
    i agree
    believe me, here in brisbane you wouldnt mention going for manly unless you were prepared for an onslaught of abuse
    didnt grow up on the northern beaches no, never been to brookie infact only been to manly once
    but i watch the doggies and feel nothing i dont feel the passion i did as a kid i couldnt even tell you half the players
    but i know everytime t rex palms someone off i am yelling and give a cheer whenever i see buhrer run on the field
    i dont care if i didnt like them as a kid, gone to every brissie/gold coast game manly have played the last few years and will do so in the future
  9. MadMarcus

    MadMarcus Local Lunatic 2017 Tipping Competitor

    +8,380 /74
    Your partner is a legend. I have converted almost all my gfs over the years. If they didn't convert by the 6 month mark they were shown the door...
  10. OneEyedEagle

    OneEyedEagle Well-Known Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

    +345 /5
    Glad you saw the light AAD.

    The youngest of my 3 nephews was a scumdog supporter and once I took him under my wing and mentored him, he to so the light and converted to being a Manly fan.

    As for the other two they had no choice or say in it and a reaping the rewards from it now.
  11. dceagle

    dceagle Active Member

    +50 /0
    Seriously , a 2nd favourite team . Pfffft

    That's like kissing your sister .... You just don't do it !

    If people need a 2nd favourite team would probably mean their 1st favourite team is probably ****e .
    • Like Like x 1
    • angryassdrummer

      angryassdrummer Member

      +5 /0
    • Jatz Crackers

      Jatz Crackers Moderator Staff Member

      +1,476 /8
      This whole 2nd team business, is for the most part nonsense.

      There are some people who support multiple teams & thats usually because they have no backbone and want an each way bet to follow a winner.

      But mostly, ive found that when fans say they have a 2nd team, in reality it means that if their favourite team they fully support dont go all the way, they have some sort of preference for another team in other games. A preference rather than actually properly supporting another team.

      IE: Any team playing the storm (provided it doesnt cruel Manlys chances) automatically becomes a preference for me.
      • Like Like x 1
      • Rex

        Rex Well-Known Member

        +2,376 /60
        According to the press, there's two types of footy supporters:

        1. Manly Supporters
        2. Haters

        You are a Hater if, and only if, you don't support Manly.

        Manly v The Haters
      • Matabele

        Matabele Well-Known Member

        +516 /14
        In the AFL everyone's 2nd team up until 2009 was Geelong because they were so innocuous. Now people hate them, though not as much as Collingwood. I recall that in 2003 the Roosters had supposedly stolen the tag from us. Well that didn't last long did it? We will become everyone's second team in a few years if Bob Reilly gets his way and scorches the Brookvale earth.
        • Like Like x 1
        • MadMarcus

          MadMarcus Local Lunatic 2017 Tipping Competitor

          +8,380 /74
          According to me there are two types of footy supporters as well:

          1. Manly Supporters
          2. Losers
        • stewartbrett(female supporter)

          stewartbrett(female supporter) Active Member

          +38 /0
          I know that Manly is labelled as "The Team Everyone Loves To Hate" and ,living down in Wollongong which is three quarters full of Dragons supporters, I'm used to comments such as 'You're Wearing The Wrong Colours' which is one comment I received one day when I was wearing one of my Manly jerseys and guess what? It was from a Dragons supporter, of course. However, I've had a theory of my own or it maybe a little similar Manly's the only team in the NRL everyone loves to hate, wouldn't that mean that fans of the other 15 NRL Teams not only support their own club but they also support 14 other clubs.

          Sure they might boo any club that their team comes up against in one round, but they're actually supporting them too. So when their club is defeated, they're not actually upset at all unless it's Manly that they're up against. Which means all other 15 NRL Clubs actually have a much wider fan base to the one they have now. So in a way, supporters of other NRL Teams have more than a second team if their club doesn't make the Grand Final.

          For example: take Sunday's game, Manly is coming up against the Warriors. Someone is, let say, an Eels supporter but they exited the finals in the qualifying game and Manly, the team everyone loathes, made it all the way to the Grand Final and they were going to verse, lets say, the Cronulla Sharks. The Eels supporters wouldn't want Manly to win so they would "cheer for the Sharks to win" even though their club are the Eels.
        • silvertail

          silvertail Well-Known Member Premium Member

          +443 /9
          Marcus is mad but true
          • Like Like x 1
          • The Eagle

            The Eagle Well-Known Member

            +480 /0
            I can live through roosters premierships,just sayin
          • Darwin Eel

            Darwin Eel New Member

            +5 /0
            Reasons as far as I've seen are; Merge and Hasler. I know many patriotic Australians for whom that hatred is strong enough they want to see the Kiwis win.

            Also; I don't believe in the whole 'second team' thing. If you have a second team then you are not a true supporter of your team. Just my opinion.

            PS: Don't lynch me. I come in peace. Just here to see if there is anything on the Manly forums supporting the rumours about T-rex on the Parra forums the last few days.
            • Like Like x 1

            Share This Page