Gidley has got to be the most overrated player in the comp. Constant mistakes, and shockingly positioned in defence. What was with his attempt on Inglis down the side as well - another mistake. He's another one of these who the media has fallen in love with but doesn't deliver. Imagine if he'd been there over Stewart (if Brett hadn't been injured) McManus - another shocking wing selection - just like the pathetic winger from the Storm - what about David Williams or anyone else? Belamy - worst NSW Origin coach ever - what's with Wing on the sideline for that long - get him on earlier. Pathetic fifth tackle plays - clearly no one new who was in charge. We had four playmakers and not one of them could organise a fifth tackle play.