MVP: Rd 10 v EELS

[Not Paul Kent]

3 Tom
2 Garrick
1 Schuster

Tom - 9
Garrick - 9
Parker - 7
Harper - 6
Saab - 8
Schuster - 8
DCE - 8
Taupau - 8
Croker - 7
Paseka - 7
Keppie - 8
Guac - 7
Jake - 7

Sipley - 8
Saddler - 4
Suli - 4
Lawton - 7

 

[Tomay]

Turbo
Parker
Shuster

 

[BOZO]

Every one played exemplary and deserve points

None more than players that were under the pump to lift and perform in a critical and pressure game and they all delivered

3 Parker.......Great to see backs score tries , and Parker scored 2
2. Garrick..... More tries
1 Crocker ......Was infrangible up the middle

Consistency is now the Key to unlock a top 4 spot

 

[The Indian]

Turbo
Keppie
Hank Scorpio

There were a dozen worthy of votes

 

[Menzies11]

Going against the grain tonight and going with defence.

- 3. Morgan Harper, every time I looked up he was smacking someone, a few times seen him come in and make 3 tackles in a row. Very impressed with this lad.
-2. Lachlan crocker, been one of his critics but has proved me wrong for many weeks now. Really starting to grow into the role, well defensively anyway.
-1. Sean Keppie. He hit them and they stay hit!!

 

[Will on the hill]

3 Tom
2 Garrick
1 Schuster

Tom - 9
Garrick - 9
Parker - 7
Harper - 6
Saab - 8
Schuster - 8
DCE - 8
Taupau - 8
Croker - 7
Paseka - 7
Keppie - 8
Guac - 7
Jake - 7

Sipley - 8
Saddler - 4
Suli - 4
Lawton - 7

Parker gets a 7? What's a ranga gotta do?

 

[TWO DOGS]

3) Keppie
2) Schuster
1) Croker

 

[Harmless27]

3. Schu
2. Turbo
1. Parker

but my god they’re all great. Harpers do good! Croker a legend too

what a team

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Was at the ground, what a day!. Manly got it done right in my 50th birthday, and for the immoral Bob Fulton as well.

Without looking at anyone elses selections I’ll give me 3-2-1

Schuster
Turbo
Garrick

But my goodness how could I leave out Sipley, Parker, Jake.

What a magnificent night.

NYEagle

Immoral Bob Fulton? Discuss.

 

[NYEagle]

Parker gets a 7? What's a ranga gotta do?

Agree here. Parker was massive. Big hit ups, big tackles, scored tries. No errors. An 8.5 or 9 all day.

NYEagle

 

[G-land Express]

Going against the grain tonight and going with defence.

- 3. Morgan Harper, every time I looked up he was smacking someone, a few times seen him come in and make 3 tackles in a row. Very impressed with this lad.
-2. Lachlan crocker, been one of his critics but has proved me wrong for many weeks now. Really starting to grow into the role, well defensively anyway.
-1. Sean Keppie. He hit them and they stay hit!!

Yeah Harper was everywhere. He does a lot of the 1%ers really well.

 

[NYEagle]

Immoral Bob Fulton? Discuss.

Thank you Terry well spotted.
Bob hasn’t been a naughty boy, I am just giddy leaving my spellcheck much to be desired!.

NYEagle

 

[NYEagle]

Going against the grain tonight and going with defence.

- 3. Morgan Harper, every time I looked up he was smacking someone, a few times seen him come in and make 3 tackles in a row. Very impressed with this lad.
-2. Lachlan crocker, been one of his critics but has proved me wrong for many weeks now. Really starting to grow into the role, well defensively anyway.
-1. Sean Keppie. He hit them and they stay hit!!

So can Croker-Lawton be a combo like Grant-Smith?. I mean he has been a massive part of this Manly resurgence and is entitled to keeping his spot on this team.

I wonder how versatile Lawton is?. I would like to see Crocker do 50-60 minutes per game in the Hooker role with Lawton either subbing or being in the field with him in a utility role.

I am so happy Croker has come good. He has never been for want of trying and the work is paying off!.

NYEagle

 

[mjb136]

I genuinely can't name a Top 3. I can't remember a whole team effort like that for a long time. Honestly who didn't deserve a point?

 

[malroon]

Parker
Keppie
Sipley

 

[ManlyTragic]

That schuster kid just keeps getting better.

 

[mosto]

Thanks @XV-1

What better way to honour the Great Man.

3 Sandwich
2 Keppie
1 Lawton

 

[IQofalimabean]

3 Turbo
2 Schuster
1 Garrick

 

[Disco]

3 Tom
2 Garrick
1 Schuster

Tom - 9
Garrick - 9
Parker - 7
Harper - 6
Saab - 8
Schuster - 8
DCE - 8
Taupau - 8
Croker - 7
Paseka - 7
Keppie - 8
Guac - 7
Jake - 7

Sipley - 8
Saddler - 4
Suli - 4
Lawton - 7

Harper made sonething like 25 tackles. Huge effort

 

[Remy]

Another great team performance that makes this really hard.

3- Turbo (absolutely everywhere on the field. Every single carry just brought chances or half chances. What a player)
2- Schuster (U can see how much he has learnt from Foz. Stayed controlled and ball played so well. Kicking game was sharp. Exceptional performance)
1- Keppie (Rattled and bitched nathan brown around. Such a huge mongrel in defence and attack)