Game Day: Manly v Panthers [Round 5, 2024]

[johnperi01]

It looked like a knock-on on face value ... but the replay clearly showed the ball went backwards.

It only looked like it went backwards because Talau moved past it; that’s a knock on every day of the week and we’d be blowing up big time if that went against us.

 

[KaZa]

Brown has been our best so far, I'm loving his work

Agree. Lodge will be similar. Can't wait till he's back

 

[Dion Johnson]

Impressed with the defensive effort after the early try was a bludger of a miss..

Ben T stiffened the right side defensively since going to right centre.

 

[HoldenV8]

Talau tried to grab the ball about a metre the Panthers side of our 10. The ball first bounced back closer to the 10 before Koula grabbed it and ran.

How anyone thinks that is a knock in is beyond me.

 

[MissKate]

So are we going to see an ‘even up the penalty count’ second half

 

[The Royal Soup]

7 errors by Manly

 

[Eagle 1]

WE ARE FUKING SH1T

Really...think you've spilt your soup, Soup

 

[eagleron]

wow

i can’t believe that

But I'll take it Soupy 👍

 

[Fibro Eagle]

Well I don’t know if that was a knock on yes he grabs at it but looks back as the ball is travelling backwards plenty go against those calls but there not always right take it when you can

 

[jbay]

It only looked like it went backwards because Talau moved past it; that’s a knock on every day of the week and we’d be blowing up big time if that went against us.

We usually do get **** call against us
So ill just enjoy one that goes our way

 

[Dion Johnson]

Ben T certainly defends better than Garrick at centre.

Fingers crossed we stop making errors in the 2nd half.

That’s his best position in my opinion in the way he plays, modern day centre for me..

 

[weev]

What are the fox commentators going on about. Often the ball goes backwards from a missed catch. Happened all the time yet they say 100 from 100 a knock on. Idiots.

 

[The Royal Soup]

So are we going to see an ‘even up the penalty count’ second half

no doubt

 

[Showbagz]

Talau tried to grab the ball about a metre the Panthers side of our 10. The ball first bounced back closer to the 10 before Koula grabbed it and ran.

How anyone thinks that is a knock in is beyond me.

Either way, I'm scared of the square ups in second half

 

[The Royal Soup]

Really...think you've spilt your soup, Soup

we are so dumb it pisses me off mate

 

[XV-1]

Talau tried to grab the ball about a metre the Panthers side of our 10. The ball first bounced back closer to the 10 before Koula grabbed it and ran.

How anyone thinks that is a knock in is beyond me.

LOL would u have the same opinion if Penrith scored the same way?

 

[The Royal Soup]

But I'll take it Soupy 👍

absolutely

 

[HoldenV8]

Either way, I'm scared of the square ups in second half

I hate agreeing with things like that but I fear you will be proved correct.....

 

[eagleron]

WOW that is extremely lucky and a poor error from the officials..

I do think it went back but I've seen a thousand the same called a knock on

 

[Ben]

I absolutely love Brown. He has the real manly mentality