Not saying you are not entitled to an opinion but how can you possibly judge a player from what you saw?
Fair enough if you get to the game but to base it on a 5 minutes of highlights, in my op, is way to harsh. You are far better judge than me if you could do it based on what you saw (the same way i would not have huge raps on any player doing great things as you can not see how many times they pushed a pass etc)
Reminds me of the old aaron groom youtube video that used to go around. You looked at it and thought he was the greatest player in the world....and we know how that turned out
Conversely how many highlight packages would matt ballin make? how often would you see him in a highlights package of our games? DOes that make him lazy or disinterested?