is it a mistake to keep Lewis?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
Yep, Brown made two half-breaks, who did we need to get the ball to? Our best player, Tom. Who called for the ball on both occasions? Our best player, Tom.

If Brown doesn't pass, takes the tackle and Tom streaks through that gap and can't be involved in the next play, then these same blokes who are bagging Brown for creating an opportunity, and passing to our best player would be bagging Brown for not passing Tom the ball and costing us the game.
name one occasion when brown did something good? we had time he didn't have to pass on both occasions he's a fool
 
name one occasion when brown did something good? we had time he didn't have to pass on both occasions he's a fool
Poor Brown. He's clearly punching way above his weight. Everyone in this thread has said what needs to be said. If Barrett picks him again then that's icing on the cake - that cake is Barrett is hopeless / useless / has no idea and should also go.
 
I watched him closely over the last 15 minutes. Here's a rough guide of what he did:
- about 1 hitup
- crowded out Walker's space
- passed twice for knock-ons
Seriously, I don't care if TB wins the Nobel Prize for solving the Korean crisis, as long as he puts LB on that field, he can never get my full support.
Rant over.
 
I watched him closely over the last 15 minutes. Here's a rough guide of what he did:
- about 1 hitup
- crowded out Walker's space
- passed twice for knock-ons
Seriously, I don't care if TB wins the Nobel Prize for solving the Korean crisis, as long as he puts LB on that field, he can never get my full support.
Rant over.
Lol, yep I don't get it either man, I really don't.
 
Paw 93. Agree with you, don't think it's the reason we lost bu

People are missing the point.
Brown did not lose us the game today, I'm not that naive... but in most of his games he makes errors in critical moments of games. I'm a proud kiwi and would be buyest to him. It's simple,he's sh$t and shouldn't play 1st grade ever again.. that's all I'm saying
Please speak English, I am one of the dumb ones who doesn't understand pigeon English, sorry.
 
I appreciate your point but tom scores tries for fun and this is a common occurrence for Brown.
One thing about manly supporters is that we never bag our own and take pride in that. This site is riddled with manly supporters being unhappy with brown. Every time I watch a game and brown is on I expect a dumb mistake from him and he always proves me right.

In here isn't the only place where Brown's spot in the side is continually questioned. Read some of the Manly pages on Facebook sometime. I swear there has not been such an unpopular player with Manly fans.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 21 17 0 4 168 40
2 Storm 21 16 0 5 252 38
3 Bulldogs 21 15 0 6 120 36
4 Warriors 21 13 0 8 12 32
5 Panthers 21 12 1 8 115 31
6 Broncos 21 12 0 9 114 30
7 Sharks 22 13 0 9 67 30
8 Roosters 21 11 0 10 92 28
9 Dolphins 21 10 0 11 109 26
10 Sea Eagles 21 9 0 12 -24 24
11 Tigers 21 9 0 12 -107 24
12 Dragons 21 8 0 13 -54 22
13 Cowboys 22 8 1 13 -144 21
14 Eels 21 7 0 14 -156 20
15 Rabbitohs 22 8 0 14 -191 20
16 Knights 21 6 0 15 -186 18
17 Titans 21 5 0 16 -187 16
Back
Top Bottom