Judiciary news

[Matabele]

Minogue has taken the early plea and will miss the next two games.

Croker will also miss the next two and therefore Origin One.

Cameron Smith and Michael Luck are contesting their charges.

 

[Fluffy]

Dissapointed - thought he would contest them, but i guess we are manly so that wouldnt do any good.

 

[Volley]

Did Kylie have any carry over points?

It's dissapointing, I thought that Timmins' hit on Hunt was alot worse.

 

[The Wheel]

The difference between Kylie & Timmins was that although both attackers were falling in the tackle, when Timmins hit hunt his arm was around his stomach/chest whislt Kylies arm was bascially parralell with his shoulder. Hard to defend that IMO.

 

[Matabele]

Minogue had carryover points from last year and received some weighting for prior offences.

He carrys a further 16 points over to the next offence, presuming there is one.

Up the top that should be Craig Smith of the Knights, not Cameron Smith.

 

[Dan]

Minogue had 57 carry over points and was charged witha grade 2 careless high tackle so misses 2 games

 

[PEPSI]

Is that definate guys, this morning 2KY said early plea = 1 game of for minogue

 

[Dan]

its definate. he has carry over points, is also listed on NRL.com

 

[The Wheel]

May 3, Round 8

NRL JUDICIARY REPORT - Round 8
Player Name Club Charge Result/ Matches/ Points
Paul Bowman Cowboys High tackle - careless Guilty - early plea 0 62
Michael Crocker Roosters High tackle - careless Guilty - early plea 2 291
Hazem El Masri Bulldogs Contrary conduct Guilty - early plea 0 93
Kylie Leuluai Sea Eagles High tackle - careless Guilty - early plea 2 216
Michael Luck Cowboys High tackle - reckless Pleading not guilty
Billy Slater Storm Contrary conduct - head slam Guilty - early plea 1 68
Craig Smith Knights Contrary conduct - head slam Pleading not guilty