Gutherson to return to Manly

Status Quo

Reserve Grader
What do my Manly comrades think about Gutherson returning to play Full Back at Manly??
Turbo to play a Free Range roaming role.
 
Brooks is a significantly better 5/8 than Gutho
Brooks has done nothing of significance in his career and his inconsistency in Big games has let him down IMO

Brooks The so called Media hype Buy of the 2024 year did not poll well in the dally M awards
Brooks was also Insignificant in the best and fairest 2024 Manly awards

2024 Manly Sea Eagles Award winners​

NRL Roy Bull Best and Fairest: Tom Trbojevic

NRL Players’ Player Award: Tom Trbojevic

NRL Leading Point Scorer Award: Reuben Garrick

NRL Leading Try Scorer Award: Tom Trbojevic

Ken Arthurson Rising Star Award: Lehi Hopoate

Menzies Medal for the Play of the Year: Jake Trbojevic

Gordon Willoughby Medallion: Daly Cherry-Evans

Manly Mentality Award: Tommy Talau

NRL Doug Daley Club Person of the Year Award: Lachlan Croker

NRL Club Wellbeing and Education Award: Karl Lawton

NRL Club Community Award: Jake Trbojevic

NSW Cup Bob Batty Best and Fairest Award: Clayton Faulalo

NSW Cup Players’ Player Award: Clayton Faulalo

Jersey Flegg Russ Bull Best and Fairest Award: Nicholas Lenaz

Jersey Flegg Cup Players’ Player: Daniel O’Donnell

The grand finalist and Inspirational leader and consistent performer Gutho is equally at home at fullback centre and 5/8 and is a Greater All round Attribute to a club than the Inconsistent Brooks IMO
 
Last edited:
The grand finalist and Inspirational leader and consistent performer Gutho is equally at home at fullback centre and 5/8 and is a Greater All round Attribute to a club than the Inconsistent Brooks IMO
Guthersons record when starting at 5/8 is 7 wins, 9 losses. Add in age and injuries and I’m not sure this is the kind of mediocrity our great club should be aspiring to.
 
Brooks has done nothing of significance in his career and his inconsistency in Big games has let him down IMO

Brooks The so called Media hype Buy of the 2024 year did not poll well in the dally M awards
Brooks was also Insignificant in the best and fairest 2024 Manly awards
Haha the dally M judges sometimes don't even watch the games.
And you forgot all about a little place where the keenest and most critical judges of Manly live - it's called Silvertails

MVP: - 2024 MVP Countdown thread
 
At what price would you see fit for him to return to Manly though, he can carry on like a pelican on the field correct me if I’m wrong but I could not see him being any big addition to the Sea Eagles
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 17 14 0 3 108 32
2 Storm 16 12 0 4 220 30
3 Bulldogs 16 12 0 4 96 30
4 Warriors 16 11 0 5 31 28
5 Broncos 17 10 0 7 80 26
6 Panthers 16 8 1 7 25 23
7 Dolphins 18 9 0 9 169 22
8 Sea Eagles 16 8 0 8 58 22
9 Roosters 16 8 0 8 21 22
10 Sharks 17 9 0 8 8 22
11 Dragons 16 6 0 10 -56 18
12 Cowboys 18 6 1 11 -163 17
13 Knights 17 6 0 11 -85 16
14 Tigers 17 6 0 11 -102 16
15 Eels 16 5 0 11 -125 16
16 Rabbitohs 17 6 0 11 -129 16
17 Titans 16 4 0 12 -156 14
Back
Top Bottom