Ex Manly team rnd1

[manlyfan76]

My team of ex Manly players named in first grade for round one. I think 1-6 would walk straight into our 3/4 line.


1 W Hopoate
2 D Whare
3 P Hiku
4 J Ramien
5 B Kelly
6 C Gutherson
7 B Green
8 D Liu
9 K Foran
10 JWH
11 S Lane
12 C Kam
13 J Buhrer

14 L Knight
15 D Gower
16 L Sao
17 F Winterstein

 

[The Wheel]

Question is who would you want back?

For me Ramien, JWH, Guthbo and Hoppa

 

[manlyfan76]

Question is who would you want back?

For me Ramien, JWH, Guthbo and Hoppa

Of the forwards only jwh would make an impact. Most of the backs would boost our round one team.

 

[Chip and Chase]

I'd have Shady Lane back and Ramien would be bloody handy at the moment. But let's face it any of those outside backs are a proven step up from Parker/Elliot/Garrick/Suli

 

[The '47ers]

My team of ex Manly players named in first grade for round one. I think 1-6 would walk straight into our 3/4 line.


1 W Hopoate
2 D Whare
3 P Hiku
4 J Ramien
5 B Kelly
6 C Gutherson
7 B Green
8 D Liu
9 K Foran
10 JWH
11 S Lane
12 C Kam
13 J Buhrer

14 L Knight
15 D Gower
16 L Sao
17 F Winterstein

Some bloody handy players there!

 

[court83]

Why is foran at 9 lol
Has he ever played hooker?? I get the point of this thread, but naming foran at hooker would be like naming someone like dce as a fullback.. Sure, he probably COULD play there, but since he never has in 20s or nrl, it would be odd to name him there..

 

[manlyfan76]

Why is foran at 9 lol
Has he ever played hooker?? I get the point of this thread, but naming foran at hooker would be like naming someone like dce as a fullback.. Sure, he probably COULD play there, but since he never has in 20s or nrl, it would be odd to name him there..

Feel free to find an ex Manly hooker who is named to play in round one.
I had left him out all together but it was the only place i could not fill.

Thanks for your contribution

 

[47MVEagle]

Would want Hoppa, Whare, Hiku & Gutherson back.

No point wanting Ramien, Kelly or Green back as they all wanted to leave - or in Ramien's case, he signed with Newcastle because he wants to be closer to family so if we had have kept him we would only have had to let him go like we did Kelly & Green.

 

[Fluffy]

My team of ex Manly players named in first grade for round one. I think 1-6 would walk straight into our 3/4 line.


1 W Hopoate
2 D Whare
3 P Hiku
4 J Ramien
5 B Kelly
6 C Gutherson
7 B Green
8 D Liu
9 K Foran
10 JWH
11 S Lane
12 C Kam
13 J Buhrer

14 L Knight
15 D Gower
16 L Sao
17 F Winterstein

Are Whare and Kelly really playing on the wings?

 

[Althewomanspal]

Will Hoppa or Gutho in place of Dylan Walker the girl beater please

 

[XV-1]

Why is foran at 9 lol
Has he ever played hooker?? I get the point of this thread, but naming foran at hooker would be like naming someone like dce as a fullback.. Sure, he probably COULD play there, but since he never has in 20s or nrl, it would be odd to name him there..

Yes he has, many times. Just ask Eddie Hayson

 

[Woodsie]

Feel free to find an ex Manly hooker who is named to play in round one.
I had left him out all together but it was the only place i could not fill.

Thanks for your contribution

Put Buhrer at hooker (he has played there at SOO) and find a different lock .... you're welcome ....

 

[ALinda]

Good thread @manlyfan76! Some of them have made it known they don't want to come back, so I wouldn't take them. However, would happily have Hoppa, Whare, Lane back and definitely Buhrer, who'd be here in a heartbeat.

 

[manlyfan76]

Are Whare and Kelly really playing on the wings?

No and Gutho named fullback.

Just had to squeeze them in somewhere.

 

[manlyfan76]

Put Buhrer at hooker (he has played there at SOO) and find a different lock .... you're welcome ....

Ah yes Origin. As much as I love Jamie his one game of origin was not worth remembering.

 

[Scorpio]

Luke Garner is starting second rower for the Tigers this Saturday.

He played in our 2015 Holden Cup GF side alongside Knight, Ramien and Tom T.

 

[EOL now nesting on the GC]

Good thread @manlyfan76! Some of them have made it known they don't want to come back, so I wouldn't take them. However, would happily have Hoppa, Whare, Lane back and definitely Buhrer, who'd be here in a heartbeat.

Still not sold on Lane. Sure he went ok last year but that was because the rest of the side was so poor and devoid of attack.
Think he might struggle out at the squeels this year.

 

[KNUCKLES]

My team of ex Manly players named in first grade for round one. I think 1-6 would walk straight into our 3/4 line.


1 W Hopoate
2 D Whare
3 P Hiku
4 J Ramien
5 B Kelly
6 C Gutherson
7 B Green
8 D Liu
9 K Foran
10 JWH
11 S Lane
12 C Kam
13 J Buhrer

14 L Knight
15 D Gower
16 L Sao
17 F Winterstein

Surely Whare is a better centre than hiku?? Id take Kelly out put gutho to fb, hoppa to wing. Foz to five eighth and bring in parcell to play 9

 

[KNUCKLES]

Still not sold on Lane. Sure he went ok last year but that was because the rest of the side was so poor and devoid of attack.
Think he might struggle out at the squeels this year.

Did he get named in the starting lineup?? I've been thinking the same thing over the off season. Thought he'd be coming off the bench at best there

 

[MadMarcus]

Man people are taking this tread seriously... you do all understand these guys aren't actually going to line up as a team right?