Define a tackle

[globaleagle]

Not saying he should be fined, but does Robinson's comment constitute referee criticism? Or does uncle Nick get it all pushed to one side?

Looking at the photo on nrl.com I can see why Thaiday is called 'third man in thaiday' (ok, 3rd man thaiday) as the pic shows him getting pwned by 4 rooster players.

 

[Harvies elbow]

Not saying he should be fined, but does Robinson's comment constitute referee criticism? Or does uncle Nick get it all pushed to one side?

Looking at the photo on nrl.com I can see why Thaiday is called 'third man in thaiday' (ok, 3rd man thaiday) as the pic shows him getting pwned by 4 rooster players.

Can you imagine little Toddy.....
"Please uncle Nick I have to fine you 10K....
Oh sorry I'll fix it. I'll fine Manly instead."

 

[maxta]

It's Dylan Napa - you actually think he goes through anything like a thought process on the field?

Yep - his thought process simple.
My job is to belt a player and give us back the edge.
Personally a fan of this attitude, can change a game and lift your team mates.

 

[maxta]

can change a game alright. He certainly changed last nights.

No - that was the interpretation of the same ref who gave Brisbane 15 straight wins .....what a surprise.....think the charge was dropped hey ??

 

[maxta]

I always thought Napa was a hot head loose cannon prone to give away crucial penalties. Guess I was wrong.

Not really mate...that’s about spot on....unconventional tackle style that is perfect for disaster....this 1 is simply a big hit that both defender and attacker got wrong