We just don’t have the middle (including 9) to compete with the heavyweights.
If we free up space with DCE’s retirement, we could buy a couple of middles but then struggle to put it together in attack and end up in the same place we are now.
I’d rather have DCE and an average middle, than a strong middle with a rookie half that can’t direct the team around or ice the 5th tackle options.
It’s easier to get away with a lack of talent in the middle, than it is to have a clueless 7.
When I read your post, 2011 come straight to mind, strong middle, rookie half, you know the story, similar principle carried us through to a robbery in 2013 and we’re all aware of the subsequent years and the outcomes.
Funnily enough the very composition of the team now and over recent years seems to be as you mention, re DCE with an average middle.
Ahhh at last some common sense.
On the surface, the replacement for DCE is a new and exciting talent wearing the same numbered jumper; problem solved? Not quite - 329 first grade games of experiences...a premiership...25 games for QLD...series wins as captain...21 games for Australia...the most golden point FG's since the format's inception...a great kicker of 40/20s...a nuanced passing game...composure under pressure...a great trainer...a strong leader...
Step on up rookie
No doubting DCE’s achievements and standing in the game, it’s definitely an impressive resume.
However he was that rookie half stepping up in 2011 behind a strong pack, remembering he also had a rookie halves partner, so interesting summation, but not necessarily definitive, so yes step on up rookie, it mightn’t be as comical as you indicate, especially given the raps on Walsh and the fact Cherry will be mentoring him.
In saying that, I think Chez will play on, unless he lifts the trophy in 26, which can happen, but I think that would be a relatively large upset given our middles and the tier 1 teams were chasing, but it’s footy and anything can happen.
If and or when our next rookie half steps up, be it Walsh, Large or perhaps another experienced replacement. l actually look forward to the new chapter, in the meantime let’s hope our middles can focus, step up and help our captain go out on a high, nothing would better.
We all know Daly’s a smart man, listening to him during the last episode of the MW he talked about achievements in the game and setting up for life after footy via footy.
I feel pretty confident in saying, Daly is hyper aware of his career stats and standing in the game and has an obvious desire to remain involved with the game in whatever capacity, after all, footy’s been his life and the sport’s never been richer. I guess the only question is, what drives him, extending his personal stat sheet to list dual premiership winner, something other or a combination of reason, only he will know.
If he plays on through 27 and has an injury free run he could move into second place for the most NRL games behind Smith, set a pretty hard club record to displace, etc. Who knows what drives him. His a complete professional and an asset to our club, whatever his motivation, here’s hoping it finishes in style, I want to take my boys to a Manly GF and I want to celebrate another Manly premiership. I think I’m having footy withdrawals, the closer the season gets the longer it seem to be taking.