It's so disappointing that it ended this way... Quite a bit of sadness but also anger, especially when you remember it all.
I'm on the younger side (probably a massive outlier compared to the lot of you) so I remember a bit of Orford, but for nearly as long as I can truly remember, DCE has been our halfback. The one constant, for better or worse. Across ups and downs in my life, good times, bad times, bloody lying women who have BPD... All of it, he's been there in the background.
As others has said, his headless chook plays have probably costed us some boring wins... But FMD, when they come off, they come off!
The past five years of miracle passes out to Saab on the wing have been a favourite of mine. The I don't think anyone will replicate those, and I don't think anyone else currently in the NRL can. The one against the Eels last year, with Turbo backing up, was probably my favourite of the lot. He threw the pass before the gap had even appeared. ****ing incredible.
Of course his golden point finishers, here's a good compilation:
This absolutely brilliant try:
And then, his hand in the best try I've ever seen by Manly:
Ultimately, I think the club failed DCE, more than he failed us. I think bringing back Watmough was a mistake, and DCE would've stayed, had it not happened.
It's not on DCE that he was never a great game manager, it was on us for expecting him to be one. It was on the club for letting Foran go. It was on the club for letting Green go. It was on the club, for yet again, letting Foran go, for ****ing Schuster of all players.
He's done some stupid things, but so has the club. I remember reading that DCE wanted to stay in 2015, but he thought he wasn't wanted as we targeted Foran... What if we went with DCE to begin with? What if he was on a lower contract, which would've allowed our talent to stay? Allowed Foran to backflip instead?
What if the club kept Api? What if the club kept Gutho? What if the club kept AFB?
DCE's shortcomings don't match that of the club. It's been a rough decade, but that rests on Scott Penn, more than the man who put his blood, sweat, and tears out for our team.