Let me start by saying that I admire the passion that the supporters on the hill that lead chants have for Manly have. I read this forum a lot and your love for Manly and it's players is very evident. However, I must say that singing a chant that labels an opposition player a pedophile completely wrong. My dislike for Billy Slater is just as strong as many of you, but I would never call anyone that. This angers me the same way as when opposition supporters call Brett a rapist. I am sure you would react strongly if someone suggested you were a pedophile, I know I would as I consider this about the lowest thing someone could think of anyone. Surely the "brainstrust" could come up with something as humorous, yet less offensive?