Post-Game Discussion Bulldogs V Manly [Finals Week 1, 2024]

[TJ55]

Just change your avatar and start supporting a champion club, TJ55… you know you want to. 😉

Thanks for the offer @HK_Eagle
We have plenty of champions here respectfully, no one will beat my all time favourite Turvey!

 

[HK_Eagle]

Fixed your typo for you, TJ55

Thanks for the offer @HK_Eagle
We have plenty of champions here respectfully, no one will beat my all time favourite Turvey Toovey!

 

[TJ55]

Fixed your typo for you, TJ55

View attachment 28238

Big call to cross the name of Steve Mortimer! A champion of the game loved by all, Toovey is a champion in his own right too🙌

 

[Jethro]

Update to Post #1

Extended Match Highlights:

Bulldogs v Sea Eagles – Finals Week 1

The Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs and the Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles face off in Finals Week 1 of the 2024 NRL Telstra Premiership

www.nrl.com

Full Match Replay Link:

Full Match Replay: Bulldogs v Sea Eagles – Finals Week 1

The Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs and the Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles face off in Finals Week 1 of the 2024 NRL Telstra Premiership

www.nrl.com

Sea Eagles Judiciary News:

• Ethan Bullemor was penalised and placed On Report at game time 33:02 for a Dangerous Tackle at game time 32:53.

The Match Review Committee have determined that only the following Manly player will be charged post-match:​

• Ethan Bullemor (Manly)
  • Grade 1 Careless High Tackle Stephen Crichton (36 min)
  • Base penalty $1500
  • 3 year incident free discount
  • His options:
    Early plea - $750
    Guilty at panel = $1000
  • PLEA: Early plea - $750

NRL Judiciary Report: Lengthy ban set to rule NAS out of decider

Storm prop Nelson Asofa-Solomona has been charged with a Grade 3 offence that carries a four-game ban after his high shot on Lindsay Collins.

www.nrl.com

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[Dion Johnson]

Have to be appreciative of the way Ciraldo spoke in his post game interviews, didn’t look for excuses and had some praise for Turbo and DCE, words of a quality human.

 

[Dion Johnson]

News Corp player ratings

NRL, Finals Week 1 2024BULLDOGS vs SEA EAGLES​

BULLDOGS

SEA EAGLES

Tom Trbojevic​

The Manly fullback looked below his best and never 100 per cent fit or comfortable, and still managed to make some magic happen.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7.5Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Tom Trbojevic





5vote

Tommy Talau​

Was put to work early scoring a try in the 15th minute to level the scores, and came up with some big hits. Penalised for one in particular that was on time, at worst.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Tommy Talau





5vote

Tolutau Koula​

Had a big job on his hands trying to wrangle Stephen Crichton and struggled to get a handle on him, but showed his class late to beat three defenders including Tracey for a magical finish.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley8Avg Fan Rating7.5
Rate Tolutau Koula





5vote

Reuben Garrick​

The Manly centre came up with some bad defensive reads on the line and had a tough afternoon handling a rampaging Viliame Kikau on his edge, but was perfect with the boot.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Reuben Garrick





5vote

Lehi Hopoate​

Was bullied on his edge but came up with a brilliant turnover in the first half, contesting the ball in the air to steal it straight from Tracey, which led to a try to Ethan Bullemor soon after.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Lehi Hopoate





5vote

Luke Brooks​

Well worked over in his first-ever finals game, but came up with a brilliant trick play from the scrum to put Daly Cherry-Evans over for Manly’s third try.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6.5Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Luke Brooks





5vote

Daly Cherry-Evans​

Caused havoc with the boot to give Ethan Bullemor a try in the first half, but came alive late with a try of his own to inspire the comeback to remind the competition how deadly he can be.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley9Avg Fan Rating8
Rate Daly Cherry-Evans





5vote

Taniela Paseka​

Did plenty of tough stuff in the middle to put fatigue into the Dogs, which paid off late.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating7
Rate Taniela Paseka





5vote

Lachlan Croker​

Looked dangerous out of dummy half as always but was made to work hard in the middle by the Bulldogs’ agile pack, making 46 tackles.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Lachlan Croker





5vote

Matthew Lodge​

Added some spark to Manly’s pack with 122 metres and seven tacklebreaks but was easily goaded into reactions that played right into the Bulldogs’ hands.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6.5Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Matthew Lodge





5vote

Haumole Olakau’atu​

Was a wrecking ball on his edge, working over Matt Burton and Bronson Xerri with some threatening runs and clocking up 130 metres, the most of any Manly forward.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley8Avg Fan Rating8
Rate Haumole Olakau’atu





5vote

Karl Lawton​

Had a quieter night compared to his star teammates but did some tough stuff with 31 tackles when the Bulldogs were on a roll.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Karl Lawton





5vote

Jake Trbojevic​

Played a solid 61 minutes through the middle and didn’t put a step wrong in defence.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Jake Trbojevic





5vote

Ben Trbojevic​

Injected some energy into a tired pack at the back end of the game, and his quick play the balls were key as momentum turned late.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley5Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Ben Trbojevic





5vote

Josh Aloiai​

His 26 minutes were effective, putting on some big hits in the early arm wrestle.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Josh Aloiai





5vote

Ethan Bullemor​

He made his 31 minutes count, scoring a try as he pushed through in support in the first half but also landed on report for a high shot on Crichton.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6.5Avg Fan Rating7
Rate Ethan Bullemor





5vote

Nathan Brown​

Stayed busy through the middle in a 35 minute stint, but didn’t see enough of his off-the-back-fence runs for just 55 metres.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley5Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Nathan Brown





5vote

Clayton Faulalo​

Did not feature.

 

[Nordburg]

News Corp player ratings

NRL, Finals Week 1 2024BULLDOGS vs SEA EAGLES​

BULLDOGS

SEA EAGLES

Tom Trbojevic​

The Manly fullback looked below his best and never 100 per cent fit or comfortable, and still managed to make some magic happen.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7.5Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Tom Trbojevic





5vote

Tommy Talau​

Was put to work early scoring a try in the 15th minute to level the scores, and came up with some big hits. Penalised for one in particular that was on time, at worst.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Tommy Talau





5vote

Tolutau Koula​

Had a big job on his hands trying to wrangle Stephen Crichton and struggled to get a handle on him, but showed his class late to beat three defenders including Tracey for a magical finish.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley8Avg Fan Rating7.5
Rate Tolutau Koula





5vote

Reuben Garrick​

The Manly centre came up with some bad defensive reads on the line and had a tough afternoon handling a rampaging Viliame Kikau on his edge, but was perfect with the boot.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Reuben Garrick





5vote

Lehi Hopoate​

Was bullied on his edge but came up with a brilliant turnover in the first half, contesting the ball in the air to steal it straight from Tracey, which led to a try to Ethan Bullemor soon after.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Lehi Hopoate





5vote

Luke Brooks​

Well worked over in his first-ever finals game, but came up with a brilliant trick play from the scrum to put Daly Cherry-Evans over for Manly’s third try.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6.5Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Luke Brooks





5vote

Daly Cherry-Evans​

Caused havoc with the boot to give Ethan Bullemor a try in the first half, but came alive late with a try of his own to inspire the comeback to remind the competition how deadly he can be.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley9Avg Fan Rating8
Rate Daly Cherry-Evans





5vote

Taniela Paseka​

Did plenty of tough stuff in the middle to put fatigue into the Dogs, which paid off late.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating7
Rate Taniela Paseka





5vote

Lachlan Croker​

Looked dangerous out of dummy half as always but was made to work hard in the middle by the Bulldogs’ agile pack, making 46 tackles.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley7Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Lachlan Croker





5vote

Matthew Lodge​

Added some spark to Manly’s pack with 122 metres and seven tacklebreaks but was easily goaded into reactions that played right into the Bulldogs’ hands.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6.5Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Matthew Lodge





5vote

Haumole Olakau’atu​

Was a wrecking ball on his edge, working over Matt Burton and Bronson Xerri with some threatening runs and clocking up 130 metres, the most of any Manly forward.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley8Avg Fan Rating8
Rate Haumole Olakau’atu





5vote

Karl Lawton​

Had a quieter night compared to his star teammates but did some tough stuff with 31 tackles when the Bulldogs were on a roll.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6.5
Rate Karl Lawton





5vote

Jake Trbojevic​

Played a solid 61 minutes through the middle and didn’t put a step wrong in defence.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Jake Trbojevic





5vote

Ben Trbojevic​

Injected some energy into a tired pack at the back end of the game, and his quick play the balls were key as momentum turned late.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley5Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Ben Trbojevic





5vote

Josh Aloiai​

His 26 minutes were effective, putting on some big hits in the early arm wrestle.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Josh Aloiai





5vote

Ethan Bullemor​

He made his 31 minutes count, scoring a try as he pushed through in support in the first half but also landed on report for a high shot on Crichton.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley6.5Avg Fan Rating7
Rate Ethan Bullemor





5vote

Nathan Brown​

Stayed busy through the middle in a 35 minute stint, but didn’t see enough of his off-the-back-fence runs for just 55 metres.
Expert RatingPamela Whaley5Avg Fan Rating6
Rate Nathan Brown





5vote

Clayton Faulalo​

Did not feature.

Croker “ Looked dangerous out of dummy half as always”.This is where I stopped reading these ratings.

 

[Niallcc]

Clear obstruction DCE was sliding across and Xerri ran on his outside shoulder and made full contact. They also scored 2 tries out of pure arse. The were lucky to get to 22 points.

Mahoney should have got sin binned the little ****ing weasel for his strike on Garrick.

Just like Josh ‘Grub’ Reynolds. I will always remember his milking a penalty by putting himself in a dangerous position to win in 2013.

 

[Status Quo]

ge said -

Score 22-20 Manly
Crowd: 38,967
motm: Turbo

close...and got close on the one that mattered!

Yes!

1AM AND ALL IS DEFINITELY WELL!!!!!

WTF????
Everything in this comment is wrong.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Lachlan Croker​

Looked dangerous out of dummy half as always

Huh?

 

[Rosko]

Winning any way at all would have been fine (of course) but to win with two brilliant tries made it... special.

 

[globaleagle]

BTW, it was good to see ex bulldog Jim Dymock, looking very happy in the Manly coaches box after the recent win!

 

[Hibyemama]

Thanks for the offer @HK_Eagle
We have plenty of champions here respectfully, no one will beat my all time favourite Turvey! View attachment 28236

I saw the mortimer brothers play live in the 70s and 80s. they have a painting of these players at the canterbury Leagues club. great facilities at your club, water-fall and all. better luck next year but not against the eagles 😆