They also gave James Roberts a 6 when he was a 4....at best. The only thing he did do all night was he actually defended well, belying his reputation as a poor defender. Other than that he didn't go looking for the ball and was barely sighted in attack.
I wouldn't read much into the media's ratings. The only ones from both sides they really got right were Tedesco and Cook.
Have you seen the Qld fans on Twitter? They're screaming blue murder that it should have been a double movement because Munster had a hand on him and was obviously making a tackle.
Munster was only going for the ball and the only reason he even had a hand on Tom's leg was because he was falling. If that is what they think is a tackle.....they're clutching at straws.
While I do agree to a point, Skivvy used to regularly belt forwards who were much taller and about 10-15 kg heavier. You didn't see 1nglis rushing up to belt Klemmer or Jake or Vaughan.
As I said last night though, Tom and 1nglis are roughly the same size (Tom is 194cm and 102 kg, 1nglis is 195 and 105) so its not like he was picking out someone who was only about the size of Tooves.