At least....

[ads]

Bailey played to expectations so we can keep blaming him.

He is no good and is a disgrace to wear the manly jearsey. His total lack of ability, other than his ability to do stupid passes and ruin our attack and to do passes/mistakes to get the other team up, totally screw us over.

If we do a 17 of Manly's worst ever players he's got to be a candidate.

 

[The Eagle]

1 Cleary
2 Donald
3
4
5 Ben Walker
6 Witt
7 Hodkinson
8
9
10
11
12 Bailey
13

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Yawn

We have the bag Bailey topic ticked off now, the Tony Williams one should be appearing soon

Bailey was pretty solid today, not great, but not crap as people will have us all believe

 

[ads]

Bailey was crap - he makes errors at critical times. You're just defending him to be contary to the threads attacking him.

Tony was really really good. Got involved and dominated in his runs.

 

[blitzkrieg]

Yawn

We have the bag Bailey topic ticked off now, the Tony Williams one should be appearing soon

Bailey was pretty solid today, not great, but not crap as people will have us all believe

Yeah KE, agreed. I'm neither here nor there with Bailey but it makes me laugh when his targetted so often - he's normally on the bench playing limited minutes and everything is his fault  :🙂

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

No I am not. What is the point in that ?

He was solid enough today

 

[eagles2win]

That side needs more Jye Mullane

 

[Moops]

1 Cleary
2 Donald
3
4
5 Ben Walker
6 Witt
7 Hodkinson
8
9
10
11
12 Bailey
13

Ivan Cleary in a worst ever XIII? You have got to be joking?

 

[The Eagle]

That side needs more Jye Mullane

Help me out dude,i didnt watch during NE era

Andrew Walker with his walkabout? ill think about that 🙂

 

[blitzkrieg]

Grant Wooden or something like that ( the Squasher or something)

 

[ads]

From what I hear Jye was so bad you wouldn't even pick him in the worst 17.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Gary Winter was special

Tony Jensen is up there with the most over rated Manly player I have seen, lived for 3-4 years off running down Wendell Sailor

 

[Moops]

Craig Field or Hodkinson at halfback?

 

[blitzkrieg]

Craig Field or Hodkinson at halfback?

Field for sure!

 

[eagle-rock08]

You blokes should get over bagging the players.  They are there and dong their best, and none of us are good enough to do the job ourselves.  If you think you are good enough strap on a boot and go and play.  Otherwise give it a rest.

 

[The Eagle]

[quote author=Moops link=topic=184904.msg288237#msg288237 date=1283067843]
Craig Field or Hodkinson at halfback?

Close call

Field for sure!
[/quote]

 

[blitzkrieg]

You blokes should get over bagging the players.  They are there and dong their best, and none of us are good enough to do the job ourselves.  If you think you are good enough strap on a boot and go and play.  Otherwise give it a rest.

I beg your pardon! I forged quite the career playing reserve grade in the bush, getting a run simply because the numbers weren't there. I believe this qualifies me to comment freely  ;D 😀 😉

 

[ads]

Hodkinson is no where near making this 17. Field well before him. I'd put Kimmorley there before him too. (You guys just seem bitter he's leaving!)

 

[The Eagle]

Im bitter that his ****,i still have alot of love for Travis Burns and he left

 

[ads]

You blokes should get over bagging the players.  They are there and dong their best, and none of us are good enough to do the job ourselves.  If you think you are good enough strap on a boot and go and play.  Otherwise give it a rest.

I assume then you don't have political opinions - seeing 'hey you've never been a politician'. And you don't have any opinions on food you eat at resturant - seeing 'hey you aren't a professional chef'. In fact I assume you keep your opinions to yourself on any topic were you aren't a professional?