Search results

  1. Rocky

    Move Heaven and Earth...

    Tevita funa? Jazz Tevaga?
  2. Rocky

    Move Heaven and Earth...

    I think he is ok in a vacuum - in fact i would start him at prop in our current team. I just dont think he has a heap of value externally given injuries, and the off field stuff. Put it this way, i wouldn't have extended him, but also wouldn't pay significant frieght to get rid of him -if that...
  3. Rocky

    Move Heaven and Earth...

    I dont recon anyone would touch him for anything over 300kish...im guessing we would have to pay decent freight.
  4. Rocky

    Move Heaven and Earth...

    The best clucb are proactive - totally agree we need to move on either Saab, Garrick or Koula...hard because i like them all.... but one needs to go if we are serious in strengthening the forward pack.
  5. Rocky

    Gutherson to return to Manly

    Brooks is a significantly better 5/8 than Gutho
  6. Rocky

    Paseka needs 2025 to be his Breaker

    He's a number 2 prop - he's shown by now he doesn't have it in him to be a true alpha leader. Thats ok - we just need to find the alpha. Given the current roster i would start with Jake and Aloiai at prop, and have Paseka off the bench for impact.
  7. Rocky

    2025

    Hey Josh yes that was obviously the plan and thanks for confirming it via your chat with Seibold. Ive defended Croker on here many times but from what last year, the team played better with Simpkin, and that was coming straight from the Tigers and learning things on the go here. I certainly...
  8. Rocky

    2025

    Everytime i see a team sheet with Jake at 13 and Croker at 9 a feel a bit deflated. Too slow, too one dimensional. And to be clear these two are high up on my favourite players. But it doesnt work and i would rather it not work with more mobile players (if that makes sense) Simpkin has to be...
  9. Rocky

    2025 recruitment & retention

    My Tigers mate says Bateman is a cancer and he would drive him to Brookvale. but if the price was 350k a season i would take the punt hoping DCE and tom and Jake keep him in line. We need an edge backrower, and for the price i think he is worth a punt.
  10. Rocky

    Ben Hunt?

    Going to cost 1m bucks - And Hunt doesn't want to play 9 at club level.
  11. Rocky

    DCE, Turbo and Seibold

    Yeah Turbo and Jake arent producing to their lofty salaries...but was there anyone on here at the time who said don't sign them and let them walk to the Dogs? This place would have burnt down in 2021 if Tom was doing what he was doing in other colours. Hindsight is a marvelous thing isnt it?
  12. Rocky

    2024 GRAND FINAL

    I hear what you are saying about the finals series - it had an air of inevitability all over it. But the GF should be a cracking game between two awesome teams.
  13. Rocky

    2025 recruitment & retention

    Thank you. Even though edge or a 13 was a higher priority, i would still have liked him here.
  14. Rocky

    2025 recruitment & retention

    Would absolutely sign him for 500k per year for 3 years. Surely we have that money.
  15. Rocky

    Ben Condon

    LOL. To be fair Condon was recruited on minimum salary. The Schuster debacle was much worse
  16. Rocky

    DCE Leads Dally M after 18 Rounds

    Other teams' fans - DCE is a legend and I would love to have him on my team Silvertails - Headless chook and turnstile on defence.
  17. Rocky

    Lodge, you Monster

    And yet there were a lot on here saying around a year ago that Manly needed to re-sign him for 500k because there were plenty of others that would!
  18. Rocky

    Lodge, you Monster

    I mean he was there for intimidation. Yet he was hugely ineffective. That sealed his fate. but yeah i take your point about our other props being average.
  19. Rocky

    Our Centers and wingers

    Should Croker be upgraded - Yes Would Manly be uncompetitive against most sides with him next year - No
  20. Rocky

    Lodge, you Monster

    Might be 150k with incentives.
Team P W L PD Pts
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0

Online statistics

Members online
7
Guests online
235
Total visitors
242
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Latest posts

Newest members

Stay Connected

Back
Top Bottom