Recent content by The Right Edge

  1. T

    These Black and white rules are still grey

    So riddle me this. A player is hit high and goes for a HIA. After 10 mins the guy who hit him is interchanged. 5 mins later player fails HIA. Who goes to the bin? Can the coach choose or must it be the player who replaced the player who made the hit. and not to further complicate it, but what if...
  2. T

    Old Autographs

    My daughter went to uni with a Manly player and they were friends. She bought me a Pepsi retro jersey and had the player get some 20 odd signatures for me. Great birthday present. Has been framed and has a place on my wall.
  3. T

    Club News 2024

    Actually, he is in the centres with Savage and Khan Pereira on the wings.
  4. T

    2024 SEMI FINALS

    Wonder what Nicho Hynes has done to Cooper Cronk. He hasn't missed him with the criticism tonight. Throws a pass to the centre who drops it, Nicho's fault for passing it too high. Turns the ball back inside to a player who drops the ball, wait its Nicho's fault he passed it too hard.
  5. T

    Game Day: Chooks V Manly [Finals Week 2, 2024]

    You have to take your hat off to the Roosters. A complete turnaround. The most penalised team in the comp, averaging 7 penalties a match, 2 ruck infringements and 1 inside 10 and with just 20 to go have conceded just 1 penalty.
  6. T

    The Anthony Seibold Grievances MEGA THREAD

    Just asking, how long have the top 2 teams had their coaches locked up for?
  7. T

    The Anthony Seibold Grievances MEGA THREAD

    Seibold has been saying it all year and it may well have been so yesterday. The win was engineered by our weapons !!! "out coached by Ciraldo??" Imagine they were ready for that scrum play that saw Saab score, Ola out wide, adjusted perfectly. But Seibold had them going the other way.. try time !!!
  8. T

    Annesley's weakly "Why this happened" report - 2024 edition.

    Will be interesting to see what happens this weekend. Round 27 was the lowest total of fines and suspensions emanating from on field reports since the 23. You may recall there was also a significant number of players sent to the bin starting in round 24. The excuse at that time was, the lead in...
  9. T

    The Anthony Seibold Grievances MEGA THREAD

    While the jury is still out in this forum here are some observations. 1) Took Lehi to Vegas - knew how good he was - appears to have protected him to the point where he can't leave him out. 2) Signed Talau again some critics of that choice in this forum, can score a try and makes some good hit...
  10. T

    Lodge, you Monster

    Yes and he called Lehi Koula and Tommy Talau Garrick even when the play was on the other side of the ground.
  11. T

    The No-Look News (Schuster Chronicles)

    Apart from Bellamy I would suggest that only Bennett can unlock the talent. Bennett's biggest challenge will be the influences he he will have around him. (if he keeps them at the club).
  12. T

    Annesley's weakly "Why this happened" report - 2024 edition.

    Lets not forget that no 2 incidents are the same and hence the rulings are consistent. The rules are written in such a way that the ref is never wrong. Most as he says are judgement calls.. the rule says that in the opinion of the referee.... etc etc. Therefore, he cannot be wrong... Then we...
  13. T

    Post-Game Discussion Manly V Warriors [Round 24, 2024]

    Butler has refereed Manly 3 times this season we have a 1-1-1 result (2 games v Warriors) In those three games we have conceded 23 penalties, 10 Ruck Infringements, 4 inside 10 and had 8 players placed on report. We have received 14 Penalties, 4 ruck infringements, 2 inside 10s and he has...
  14. T

    Annesley's weakly "Why this happened" report - 2024 edition.

    So the 45 sec review of the Saab incident wasn't enough to make a call other than put on report.A) They assessed it was the arm that hit him and it slipped up. They failed to see the shoulder make the hit. Bunker doesn't know if the player is injured - Saab left the field for HIA immediately...
  15. T

    Jake Simpkin signed until 2026

    Wasn't Damian Cook at 24 years of age stuck behind the great Michael Lichaa, wasn't rated by Des, left and went to Souths went on to play state of origin? Not saying that Simpkins is in that league yet, however may develop.
See more
Team P W L PD Pts
1 1 0 38 4
2 2 0 16 4
1 1 0 36 2
1 1 0 30 2
1 1 0 22 2
1 1 0 8 2
1 1 0 6 2
1 1 0 2 2
0 0 0 0 2
1 0 1 -2 0
1 0 1 -6 0
1 0 1 -8 0
2 0 2 -16 0
1 0 1 -22 0
1 0 1 -30 0
1 0 1 -36 0
1 0 1 -38 0

Online statistics

Members online
71
Guests online
777
Total visitors
848
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Latest posts

Newest members

Stay Connected

Back
Top Bottom