I think every Manly fan would have Killer in their top 3. He is all class and he has really led by example, he's really stepped up to the duties of a captain. Some brilliant plays that had a significant impact on our season, most notably the play that won the game against the sharks.
Gift was consistent and brilliant, he took so much pressure off the halves and never had a quiet game.
My initial thoughts were DCE but Snake's more limited involvement through the season was top shelf. From the try saver against the Donkeys to the opening try in the GF, his work in attack and defense all season was better than any other fullback in the game. Having said that, DCE built through the season and we would not be premiers without him.
Foz was good but faded towards the back of the season, Joe was fantastic, Hoppa was a class above on the wing and Robbo was Robbo, probably the most consistent winger I've ever seen. The fact that almost every player played well every time they took the field was the reason they took home the trophy. Even George was averaging over 100m a game off the bench.