Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by Shnorky, Apr 25, 2015.
I thought it was shoulder off the ball, will we be without another centre in coming weeks?
I didn't even think there was any contact with the head. He should get off no problems.
We should also get an apology for the penalty against stewart
Nappa did two in one game that was a shoulder.
Matai should get an apology for character assassination by Ceccin
Yeh Stewart penalty was a joke let alone on report
Yeah but it's Maria, he could be tieing his shoelaces and still get 2 weeks, thought there wasn't much in it though
0 weeks. nothing to warrant a penalty let alone suspension
Neither brett or matai will get time.
Both penalties were a joke.
Matai's first contact is with his body and the blokes head accidentally fell into Matai's shoulder. Shouldn't have even been a penalty
Stewart's was the worst call I've seen for a while. Have they totally lost touch with the fact that RL is a contact sport. That was a pathetic call and Archer should come out and say so.
6 weeks after Greenturd files his preferences.
Matai plays for Manly. 6 weeks.
Both penalties were bullsh1t.
Both shouldn't have been penalized to begin with.
What are we playing here? Touch?
Ceccin tried his best tonight to bend us over again...Pardon the pun.
Both teams copped bad decisions. The decision to put Stewart on report was done by the video ref not cecchin. I missed the matai one but Stewart should have nothing to answer too.
I missed the Stewart one but the matai one was laughable.
0 weeks for the tackle and 6 weeks manly loading.
Both ridiculous - the Stewart one in particular. To show action like this in slow motion totally distorts realty. I hate the video ref, but it's made worse when they don't rule on the incident in real time. The match is played in real time, with real reactions and reflexes.
Boy the NRL has stuffed up so many aspects of this sport!
0 weeks. Matai is made a victim because of the tough way he plays. I'll never forget the time time he flattened George Burgess with a ferocious and legal shot at Brookvale. George stayed down as if he was a victim or foul play and Sam came in to shove Matai in the back. Matai was put on report but IIRC, there was no case to answer.
It will be the same this time around as well. He will have no case to answer.
I can understand how the ref might have penalised Matai. Seeing it live from his angle it might have looked like he hit him high, but wit the benefit of the replay for the video ref to deem reportable was a disgrace. Dylan Napa got a very similar penalty against him today against the dragons. The Stewart one was just laughable.
you forgot the part where he laid Big Sam out two tackles later after the penalty haha.
Separate names with a comma.