We are embarrassing - winning the comps is years away.

[wombatgc]

It's a mental thing. We have the physical ability but we get to a decent lead and completely change how we play. We go from fast and fluid to nervous and clunky.

Agree. We are the worst front runners in the comp. 20-4 at half time, most fans are thrilled. Not this one. Game management goes out the fkn door as soon as we get a decent lead.

 

[NYEagle]

I said in that in 2008

In Round 23 Bunnies (14th) put 40 on us after the Roosters flogged up 32-12 in Round 20.

Not that I rank this team of milk drinkers in the same stratosphere as our mighty 08 side.

I think they had some Canberra Milk tonight.

NYEagle

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

We are blaming DCE for the intercept try, the Waddell drop that led to a try, the pathetic Lodge kick off effort, and Saab dropping the bomb at the end ?

More embarrassing for me is the signing and extending of Lodge rather than anything Manly does on the field

 

[Chunkytuna]

Our record of a premiership every decade has come to an end, we are miles away from having a team capable of winning a competition.

Can’t disagree with this. It’s Fuken miserable.

 

[KNUCKLES]

We are blaming DCE for the intercept try, the Waddell drop that led to a try, the pathetic Lodge kick off effort, and Saab dropping the bomb at the end ?

More embarrassing for me is the signing and extending of Lodge rather than anything Manly does on the field

To be fair with the waddell drop, DCE through that bloody rocket in wet conditions.

 

[HK_Eagle]

To be fair with the waddell drop, DCE through that bloody rocket in wet conditions.

Yep, and high at his shoulder too

 

[Will on the hill]

It's DCEs team, it's DCEs style, it's DCEs brain snaps every week. I'm sorry but it starts and ends with him. Even when we were 20 up I was fkn yelling at the tele with his stupid play. Bcoz I just knew this would happen. It's rugby league not bloody touch footy. Respect the ball!!!

Thought he was one of our best for the majority of the game but the pass that 7ft tall Saab had to jump to catch while standing next to the sideline, in the wet, on the first tackle would've been a droppable offence if it was a rookie.

Hate to say it but with hindsight I wonder if we'd have been less complacent if Chez hadn't of gotten off and Arthur played. Stupid, I know but Raiders beat us by playing the kiss strategy and we tried to out think what should've been a simple game.

 

[Ned]

People get over emotional on here sometimes, after a win too optimistic and after a loss too catastrophic. Yes we should've won that, the drops and errors and 6 agains killed us as kiwi eagle mentioned. Clean that up and we're going good, not saying premiership but in semi's for sure, anything can happen then, especially if turbo starts firing. Not embarrassing, I'd say frustrating.

 

[KNUCKLES]

Thought he was one of our best for the majority of the game but the pass that 7ft tall Saab had to jump to catch while standing next to the sideline, in the wet, on the first tackle would've been a droppable offence if it was a rookie.

Hate to say it but with hindsight I wonder if we'd have been less complacent if Chez hadn't of gotten off and Arthur played. Stupid, I know but Raiders beat us by playing the kiss strategy and we tried to out think what should've been a simple game.

He plays well when the touch footy stuff pays off but the thing is it's not gonna pay off all game long. He tries his hand way to often for mine. He needs to adapt to the game. Imagine cleary or cronk or Reynolds in this game tonight. They'd just continually chip away, build pressure and break the other team down. 20 nil up they manage the win. But nope.. not our captain. The conditions would of suited Arthur tonight, we probably don't jump out like we did but I think it would of been a completely different type of game we could of won

 

[The Royal Soup]

won’t win **** with this embarrassing bunch of woke soft coks that won’t defend there line

 

[Nordburg]

Rd1 conceded 24 points to Souths
Rd2 barely beat the Roosters at home despite having enough ball to win 3 games
Rd3 lost to Eels
Rd4 lost to the pathetic Dragons(granted,they always lose at the Gong
Rd5 beat a Cleary-less Panthers(won’t be too critical given nobody takes away wins against a TomT-less Manly)
Rd6 draw against NZ after leading by 16(unlucky by games end but….)
Rd7 extremely piss poor win conceding 30 against the Titans
Rd8 beat the Eels but was hardly convincing other than the 20 minutes after halftime
Rd9 less said the better
I could do the same with last season and it would read almost exactly the same.Even the wins last year,other than end of season junk time wins,had question marks over them.Seibold talks up a good game,but he’s done nothing with the teams defence and attitude,same problems he had at the Broncos

 

[themanwithnoname]

Our forwards looked flat and didn't run as hard as Canberra's forwards. Our defensive line speed wasn't great either.

 

[Nordburg]

People get over emotional on here sometimes, after a win too optimistic and after a loss too catastrophic. Yes we should've won that, the drops and errors and 6 agains killed us as kiwi eagle mentioned. Clean that up and we're going good, not saying premiership but in semi's for sure, anything can happen then, especially if turbo starts firing. Not embarrassing, I'd say frustrating.

That’s the problem,their not going good.The attack is fine,but it’s masking over pathetic defence and a lack of resilience and composure,same as last season.May say 5 wins but nothing has been convincing

 

[wedgetail eagle]

I know it’s unrealistic to think the goal kicker will kick every goal.
But, spare my days….
Maybe Garrick’s old injury is giving him trouble again?

 

[skull61]

Especially if we keep signing plodders like Lodge and Brown

 

[mickqld]

The kick in their own 30 to Garrick in the first half,sums up part of the teams issue.It may of come off,but given the conditions and circumstances,it was unnecessary.

Yeah and then Turbo was running in front of him and Garrick couldn't pass to him. Turbo's head was off in lala land tonight same as the Dragons game.

 

[Hertera]

Not embarrassing

20 nil up at home win the penalty count 8-3 against a team with rookies in the halves and 3 players we deemed not good enough for us in weekes,levi and hopoate if that isn't embarrassing what is?

 

[mickqld]

I just feel sorry for Jake. He's tries his guts out every week but he'll never win a premiership surrounded by these turkeys.

 

[niccipops]

We are blaming DCE for the intercept try, the Waddell drop that led to a try, the pathetic Lodge kick off effort, and Saab dropping the bomb at the end ?

More embarrassing for me is the signing and extending of Lodge rather than anything Manly does on the field

Had a hand in all tries including scoring one.
Due to the contract saga in 2015 which was the Manly club's fault, the DCE bagging is never going to end.

 

[Dion Johnson]

How we lost that is beyond me. We concede a ridiculous amount of metres in defence and get very complacent whenever we are in the lead.

The comp is years away - we don’t have the discipline and the intensity to win.

The thing is all these areas can be rectified, I wouldn’t say this season is out of reach for this group.

Need a couple of changes with the 17 and they will be back on track with their season.

Hopefully Seibold is brave with the 17 this week and we have 8 weeks to fill the four vacant spots in the top 30.