The 8th Immortal to be named this year.

[bob dylan]

I notice in RLW they have put I together a panel to add another immortal.

Contenders seem to be

Andrew Johns
Mal Meninga
Brad Fittler
Norm Provan
Peter Sterling
Lauren Daley
Darren Lockyer
Alfie Langer


Personally I hope its Provan or Ron Coote or Noel Kelly.

 

[Jono]

I notice in RLW they have put I together a panel to add another immortal.

Contenders seem to be

Andrew Johns
Mal Meninga
Brad Fittler
Norm Provan
Peter Sterling
Lauren Daley
Darren Lockyer
Alfie Langer


Personally I hope its Provan or Ron Coote or Noel Kelly.

It has to go to Norm Provan before the others. Why he isn't already I do not know. The rest haven't been around long enough in service of the game to deserve the title of immortal yet.

I'd go: Provan, Sterling, Meninga, Johns, Menzies, Lockyer

 

[Cameron]

Johns or sterling

**** the qlders

 

[WAMF]

Johns should be inducted as an Emmortal.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

It should be a forward. They are under-represented so far, considering the role they play in the game.

 

[Dan]

I can't believe I haven't made the list

 

[bazeagle]

Me too Dan. I also reckon I should be the next Immortal, for outstanding service to the forum.

 

[jbb/james]

Me too Dan. I also reckon I should be the next Immortal, for outstanding service to the forum.

Thought you might have been pushing david gallops inclusion baz

 

[bones]

Jye Mullane for mine.

 

[Captain Moondog]

Possibly John Hopoate?

 

[Cameron]

Chris bailey

 

[bones]

Possibly John Hopoate?

He might be the first immoral.

 

[Dan]

hmmm maybe we need to start our own Manly Immortals and Forum Immortals

 

[TWO DOGS]

From that list, Norm Provan but I would like to see Ken Irvine added to the possibles.

 

[Dan]

Provan owns the Beach House hotel (pub) up here, actually he has it up for sale at the moment

 

[weev]

Where's Luke Dorn?

 

[Dan]

Jye Mullane would be a Silvertails Immortal

 

[bones]

Am I biased in thinking Steve Menzies should be on the list? I can't help but feel that had he played for a team that was strong for his whole career, or if manly didn't go through that crappy period between 99 - 2004 he would be. In my mind he is equal to any back rower I have ever seen. Is it anti manly biased or is he paying the price for Manlys lean years in the middle of his career? Or is he not as good as I rate him?

 

[Captain Moondog]

Possibly John Hopoate?

He might be the first immoral.

Joel Monaghan at number two.

 

[bones]

Possibly John Hopoate?

He might be the first immoral.

Joel Monaghan at number two.

Number two? Julian O'Neill would be a shoe in.