No consistency from this bloke. He gave penalties for certain indiscretions but when QLD held down there was nothing forthcoming. When NSW were coming off their line the 10 m was non-existent. That penalty he gave that allowed Lockyer to kick for goal in the last few minutes was diabolical and was so wrong it wasn't funny. Qld had done worse at least three or four times and yet they got away scot free and he gave that penalty when the game was up for grabs. Very poor game and a few wrong decisions both ways.