Keep Starling

[sheridanstand78]

Starling is one of those no frills players that every team needs that gets the hard metres and compliments the players with more flair around him, hes getting his match fitness now and he will do well in the last 4 games.

 

[manlywarringah]

A definate keeper.

Sadly our owners and joe Kelly are idiots so who knows what they'll do!

 

[BOZO]

Based on the performances of the last two weeks we should be keeping all 17 of them

It is a shame why they didn't produce this form earlier in the season

 

[Fluffy]

Doubt there are many bigger supporters that me but i cannot fathom getting rid of him play him behind Jake and myles and we are looking sweet

 

[robbiea]

I think we will keep either Starling or Willie ,might come down to the cheapest option.

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Josh, the 2014-15 version of Glenn Hall.

 

[manlyfan76]

A definate keeper.

Sadly our owners and joe Kelly are idiots so who knows what they'll do!

In Starlo's favour is that he has played with souffs.

 

[HappilyManly]

It is a shame why they didn't produce this form earlier in the season

Starlo has been out injured all year, along with BJ

Manly had so many forwards and backs out, it's amazing that we beat the Scumos twice early on

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

It is a shame why they didn't produce this form earlier in the season

Last year they tried starting well and leading he comp all season and it just doesn't work, this year they decided to try something different.

 

[JenEagle]

I reckon we should keep Starling and Matt Ballin. we'll have great depth then. Keep willie too if we can afford it.

 

[maxta]

Something that has always been overlooked with Starling is his defence.
Very rarely misses a tackle & have noticed again last night........
Every line break he seems to be flashing across in cover defence - rare for a front rower

 

[Dee Why Eagle]

Something that has always been overlooked with Starling is his defence.
Very rarely misses a tackle & have noticed again last night........
Every line break he seems to be flashing across in cover defence - rare for a front rower

We'd be crazy to let him go....
Need to keep Willie too - would be awesome off bench

 

[The Who]

He was terrific again from the bench. If 2V decides to bring in Lawrence we'll have an extremely competitive forward pack.

 

[Scorpio]

Starling MUST be there next year. Another great performance on Friday night.

Mid-way through last year he was looking decidedly average, ever since the finals game against the Bulldogs he has been excellent.

If he gets turfed to make way for Lussick I will not be happy.

 

[tookey]

A definate keeper.

Sadly our owners and joe Kelly are idiots so who knows what they'll do!

Starling needs to put up a highlights video on youtube to be re-signed. Either that or change his name to Josh Starling

 

[Rex]

Something that has always been overlooked with Starling is his defence.
Very rarely misses a tackle & have noticed again last night........
Every line break he seems to be flashing across in cover defence - rare for a front rower

What I like most about Starling is that his raw strength (like Jake's) tightens the ruck area. If we don't stop the big boppers up the middle, then our wide defence is easily outnumbered, making wingers look like poor defenders.

Big scores were being put on Manly while Starling was out injured. Now he's back, look at the difference in go forward (attack & defence). It's not just him returning from injury, but his return has contributed significantly to the solidity of Manly's defence.

 

[Clay]

I always get starling and Leary mixed up.
Or I think its teh same player and be like wow his had atleast 30 hit-ups this game

 

[NYEagle]

What I like most about Starling is that his raw strength (like Jake's) tightens the ruck area. If we don't stop the big boppers up the middle, then our wide defence is easily outnumbered, making wingers look like poor defenders.

Big scores were being put on Manly while Starling was out injured. Now he's back, look at the difference in go forward (attack & defence). It's not just him returning from injury, but his return has contributed significantly to the solidity of Manly's defence.

Add workaholics like Leary and Balin playing big minutes and that's your engine room. Everything happens from there for the likes of Jake T, Horo and Symonds.

 

[Fluffy]

Last year was his first full year in the top grade and he improved a lot as the year went on. Always thought this year he would be good for us,a shame he got injured early but now he is back we look better. Take out your 2 starting front rowers and you struggle simple as that.

Myles and Jake as starters with Starling off the bench next year and the 4th prop doesn't need to be a superstar.

 

[Hamster Huey]

13 hitups 135 meters 26 tackles off the bench. And made some good covering plays in D.

It's this cover defence that most impresses me. Shows (a) he can read what's unfolding, and (b) he's taking responsibility to be there and stop it. A very good cornerstone for the pack over the coming years.