Coach of the year

[rmd]

i can’t disagree with his win. He did obviously is a brilliant coach. Des did amazing things for us, Arthur did great things for the Eels and Robinson for the Chooks.

So, if bellyache offered to coach the Eagles, would you say no?

 

[Harvies elbow]

i can’t disagree with his win. He did obviously is a brilliant coach. Des did amazing things for us, Arthur did great things for the Eels and Robinson for the Chooks.

So, if bellyache offered to coach the Eagles, would you say no?

Atm definitely

 

[MuzztheEagle]

i can’t disagree with his win. He did obviously is a brilliant coach. Des did amazing things for us, Arthur did great things for the Eels and Robinson for the Chooks.

So, if bellyache offered to coach the Eagles, would you say no?

Would not want him anywhere near the club! Take away the salary cap years, take away the junior system, the resources, the media isolation and the clear bias in games and off the field and I doubt he would rate anywhere near where he currently does. Sure they took out the minor premiership by a far margin but, Bellamy hasn't brought anything new to his game this year and against top teams they have been ordinary. And that is what ended up counting and was why they were bundled out of the finals in straight sets.

 

[HappilyManly]

If you compare the resources Bellyache has had including his roster up to and including 2019 with the game's best ever player, obviously his results are as expected.

He failed as the Blues coach and has never been tested at a Club that is rebuilding

 

[Budgie]

Least deserving got it. Two GF coaches, two who took their teams from 15th and 16th to 5th and 6th. and the guy who's team went from grand finalist to losing both playoff games.
Yep. Give it to that guy.
Joke.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Least deserving got it. Two GF coaches, two who took their teams from 15th and 16th to 5th and 6th. and the guy who's team went from grand finalist to losing both playoff games.
Yep. Give it to that guy.
Joke.

This ^^^^^ 150%

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

But full marks (cough) to his dresser for making him look like a cross between a butcher and a Darrell Lea salesperson. Tasteful stuff.

Not to mention Bellamy’s Strop-like speech patterns.

Craig Stropamy.

 

[globaleagle]

Seems to me that the 2019 Dally M's is the 'year of the grubs' - mostly.

 

[eagle abroad]

wouldn't change our beautifully flowing maned nose whistling nutter for anyone....

 

[madmax]

i can’t disagree with his win. He did obviously is a brilliant coach. Des did amazing things for us, Arthur did great things for the Eels and Robinson for the Chooks.

So, if bellyache offered to coach the Eagles, would you say no?

YES! With the roster he has any coach would basically do well. Let's see how he'd go with a weak roster!

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

YES! With the roster he has any coach would basically do well. Let's see how he'd go with a weak roster!

I’m more interested to see how he goes sans Scam400, who knows he might convince him to be Scam500 so he can win a few more awards.

I asked this question in the Dally M thread about who picks these awards.

I understand who gives the Dally M points each game BUT who picks Coach of the Year etc???

 

[Waz13]

There’s two coaches at that club, one just win captain of the year. Slater, cronk outstanding players but replaceable imo. His test will be when Smith goes.

 

[niccipops]

I would NEVER want Bellamy over Des.

 

[BOZO]

Coach of the year who exceeded all expectations

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I’d imagine even Bellyache would have been embarrassed by that last night.

Either of the Dalai or Desmond were the logical choice.

 

[QueefRichards]

I dont see the issue here. Bellamy is a great coach, and Melbourne's regular season was immense.

There is only one thing that counts for Manly, and that's winning the grand final. We are building for it.

 

[QueefRichards]

Coach of the Year is less prestigious than tackle of the year btw

 

[Chip and Chase]

I don't understand people banging on about Arthur's performance in taking a team from a Wooden spoon to 6th ??? FMD he was the one who coached them to a wooden spoon last year !!!!

Des turned around a side he inherited from a clown, that ran second last and looked woeful - he transformed them into a premiership threat within a season with minimal change in roster and a not insignificant injury toll. That performance by Des $hits all over the Dalai's - not even in same ballpark

 

[deanm]

I don't understand people banging on about Arthur's performance in taking a team from a Wooden spoon to 6th ??? FMD he was the one who coached them to a wooden spoon last year !!!!

Des turned around a side he inherited from a clown, that ran second last and looked woeful - he transformed them into a premiership threat within a season with minimal change in roster and a not insignificant injury toll. That performance by Des $hits all over the Dalai's - not even in same ballpark

Exactly & didn’t Parra finish 4th in 2017 ?

 

[grassy]

Bellamy looked like a licorice allsort, that reminds me I have domino’s tonight. I dunno what it is, but I am getting the incling to put my bobby crush cd on.