1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Who Is the Next Immortal?

Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by Sideline Eye, Oct 13, 2015.

  1. Sideline Eye

    Sideline Eye Active Member

    +164 /4
    Interesting article in the DT regarding the next possible immortal and the rules which apply when consideration potential inductees. Whilst I believe Thurston will eventually become an immortal, I don't mind the idea of Meninga becoming the 10th inductee especially when you consider not just his playing career but the success he has had as a coach of the QLD side.

    Your thoughts.
  2. mozgrame

    mozgrame Well-Known Member

    +5,134 /51
    Thurston for sure. However, there should be an award given to Brett Stewart. He has been through so much in his career with success, injury, off field crap. He'll never be an immortal, but in my eyes he is a champion of the highest order. Imagine the heights he could have reached in the game without the injuries. Then there's the diabetes. He is a dead set champion!

    Long live Snake!
    • Like Like x 3
    • Winner Winner x 2
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Optimistic Optimistic x 1
      Last edited: Oct 13, 2015
    • Snake

      Snake Doing The Eagle Rock!

      +5,082 /244
      this is my favourite post of all time on Silvertails!
      • Like Like x 1
      • NewwyEagle

        NewwyEagle I sleep in a racing car

        +1,464 /72
        I'm of the opinion that people are throwing around this "Immortal" term far too much. Inglis, Smith, etc are not immortals. I can accept Thurston being one but I personally wouldn't vote for him to be, and especially not Meninga. Lockyer missed out when Johns was selected, if he wasn't good enough to be selected in 2012 he's not good enough to be selected in 2016.
        • Agree Agree x 6
        • SeaEagleRock8

          SeaEagleRock8 Sea Eagle Lach Staff Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

          +10,572 /215
          Never saw him play, but the fact someone with the record of Norm Provan hasn't made it casts a bit of a shadow over the concept. It seems to have been overtaken with the Channel 9 fixation on declaring a new 'greatest player of all time' just about every year in a thinly disguised bid to bump viewing ratings.
          • Winner Winner x 1
          • qldeagle

            qldeagle Well-Known Member

            +1,230 /51
            • Funny Funny x 4
            • Winner Winner x 3
            • HoldenV8

              HoldenV8 Well-Known Member

              +10,540 /173
              Mal Meninga has to be made an Immortal before Thurston.

              * 1981 and 1985 BRL Premiership player with Souths Magpies
              * 1989, 1990 and 1994 NSWRL Premiership captain of the Canberra Raiders
              * 1982, 1986, 1990 and 1994 Kangaroo Tourist, the only player in history to make four tours and the only player to captain the squad twice (1990 and 1994)
              * 46 test matches for Australia, 23 as captain.
              * Captained Australia to series wins over Great Britain (1990, 1992 and 1994), New Zealand (1991 and 1993), France (1990, 1994) and Papua New Guinea (1991)
              * Captained Australia to win the 1992 World Cup Final
              * 32 Origin games for Qld, 12 as captain
              * 7 games for Qld under the old State of Residence rules
              * 1990 Golden Boot winner as the best player in the world
              * Qld Team of the Century 1908-2007
              * ARL Team of the Century 1908-2007
              * 2003 ARL Hall of Fame inductee
              * Coached Qld to 9 Origin series wins in 10 years including 8 in a row from 2006-2013

              For my money he should be an immortal already and if not for the NSW bias from the selection panel at the time he should have been made one either before or in place of Andrew Johns.
              • Agree Agree x 1
              • Disco

                Disco Well-Known Member

                +1,778 /48
                The whole Immortal concept is tosh atm, it's decided ad hoc to boost RLW sales

                The NRL needs to take control, keep the current imortals than induct 1 per decade

                Should be cream of the crop, Lockyer, Smith, Inglis should not be immortals

                Then the NRL need to sort out the hall of fame, boost the numbers to 20 in one go the induct two players per year. Hall of fame should be for players like Menzies, Eadie, Stewart, Toovey, Lyons, Sterling, Kenny, Lamb, Stuart, Daley, Fittler, Lamb etc etc

                Announce the players in GF week, immortals are obviously in bothAlso make a rule that you cant be an Immortal until 5 years after retirement, let the hype settle before you put Thurston ahead of Meniga, Proven etc
                • Agree Agree x 1
                • Fluffy

                  Fluffy Well-Known Member

                  +5,631 /205
                  Beaver should be an immortal.

                  over 500 first grade games, try scoring record for a forward, 2 premierships in the modern day, heaps of work off the field and squeaky clean unlike Johns, Lockyer, Thurston, Meninga.
                  • Agree Agree x 2
                  • Winner Winner x 1
                  • tookey

                    tookey Well-Known Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

                    +5,801 /186
                    Norm Provan should be next
                    • Agree Agree x 4
                    • Mark from Brisbane

                      Mark from Brisbane Living the dream Premium Member

                      +19,684 /383
                      I dislike the fact that a magazine runs this, they may have started it but it should be awarded now by the NRL.

                      I would think Meninga should be next, and then Thurston 10 years later, but I also think it's a travesty that Norm Provan has been overlooked , and he may not have much more time left to be around if in fact they see the error of their ways.
                      • Agree Agree x 2
                      • Peter C

                        Peter C Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

                        +1,207 /26
                        Meninga certainly a Hall of Fame player, as is Provan, Coote, Locky, Inglis etc, but he's certainly no immortal, as a matter of fact his statements during the Super League War as the recently retired Australian captain at the time, should automatically disqualify him.
                        As for his coaching record, Queensland were blessed for ten years with the best players, simple.
                        • Agree Agree x 3
                        • Dummy Spit Dummy Spit x 1
                        • Jase Seaeagle

                          Jase Seaeagle Active Member

                          +167 /15
                          Meninga for sure or Normy Provan.Nice Bloke to go with it. But Definitely J.T in years to come.
                        • Bandit

                          Bandit Well-Known Member

                          +169 /5
                          Ron Coote, Steve Rogers this induction.

                          Meninga, Locky, Beaver, Laz & Webcke, JT, Cam Smith & Inglis in the future.

                        • double hoops

                          double hoops Well-Known Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

                          +3,721 /156
                          Who? Who cares. The whole thing is a total wank. Subjective much.
                        • simon64

                          simon64 Well-Known Member Premium Member

                          +2,548 /32
                          Beaver won't be an immortal. But he should be.
                          I don't begrudge Thurston. Say what you like, the guy is a rare talent.
                        • Mal Cochrane

                          Mal Cochrane I'm not really Mal Cochrane...

                          +593 /4
                          Johns was put in too early. Meninga most definitely, his record, especially rep footy speaks for itself whether you like him or not. Think about Lockyer and Thurston later, and please, don't ever think about Fittler.
                          • Agree Agree x 1
                          • bones

                            bones Bones Knows

                            +9,037 /102
                            Provan is already immortalised in Rugby League by being on the Premiership trophy, and rightly so. He should also be an 'immortal'.
                            • Agree Agree x 1
                            • Lyonstomenzies

                              Lyonstomenzies Well-Known Member Premium Member

                              +997 /23
                              Lyons and Menzies.
                            • Frogz

                              Frogz Well-Known Member Premium Member

                              +1,934 /43
                              Mal Meninga...What did Rugby League ever do for me...Fark him....

                              No more immortals, hall of famers maybe...The last knob didn't deserve his status.
                              • Agree Agree x 2

                              Share This Page