Top five worst Manly Players

[COMMANDER]

Go.

Brad Parker is in there, along with the guy they promoted from the Penal League in 2004 when they couldn't afford to spend the salary cap. Shane Winters.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Lol win 3 on the bounce and this is the best you can come up with

 

[Ryan]

Go.

Brad Parker is in there, along with the guy they promoted from the Penal League in 2004 when they couldn't afford to spend the salary cap. Shane Winters.

Gary Winter was his name.
Brad Parker is far from being worst.

Others that spring to mind:
Dragan Durdavec
Shane Neumann
David Vaeliki

 

[BOZO]

Go.

Brad Parker is in there, along with the guy they promoted from the Penal League in 2004 when they couldn't afford to spend the salary cap. Shane Winters.

Mate , our team defied the odds and won today

It was a great team effort

 

[Freagle]

Seriously, get a life. Parker was far from bad - in fact, one of our better players defensively.

 

[mave]

Unsuprising contributions, from the usual negative suspects.

 

[DUFFMAN]

This topic has come up plenty of times and the winner is always Craig Field.

 

[brad]

Gary Winter was his name.
Brad Parker is far from being worst.

Others that spring to mind:
Dragan Durdavec
Shane Neumann
David Vaeliki

Mark Shipway .

 

[Freagle]

This topic has come up plenty of times and the winner is always Craig Field.

I’d give you a “funny” and an “agree”, but there is only room for one...

I actually recall watching field, back in the day. Was on the Hill, and supporters around me were giving him heaps...and I remember thinking.. “but he’s a Manly player...you can’t pay out on our own players!” AND...then I watched out for him for the next few games. And I saw the effort getting back on side...and backing up his players...and standing too deep or too shallow to actually get the ball oin a good position...and the sight of his pea-sized heart masquerading as a Manly player... and yeah... Craig Field...

 

[Brissie Kid]

Jorgen Rogers. 1 game. Fullback in Rd 1 1994. Watch this great fullback cover tackle (not) at the start of the game. Other Dogs tries come as Manly has no fullback! Gone missing!

 

[Freagle]

Jorgen Rogers. 1 game. Rd 1 1994. Watch this great fullback cover tackle (not) at the start of the game.

You’ve played well my friend...I pride myself on recalling every Manly player from the last 35 years or so...but that one had slipped by me.

 

[Brissie Kid]

You’ve played well my friend...I pride myself on recalling every Manly player from the last 35 years or so...but that one had slipped by me.

I just remember it as it was so horrendously memorable! Grahame Lowe found Ridge and Rodgers in NZ rugby. Talk about rocks and diamonds.

 

[manlyfan76]

N
A
T
E

M
Y
L
E
S

 

[FlyingHigh]

Lewis Brown

 

[PONTIAN SEA EAGLE]

I’m on such a high at the moment I can’t think of anything negative.

 

[Freagle]

N
A
T
E

M
Y
L
E
S

Can’t agree... He had a dig, was just well past his best by the time we got him. He still controlled the ruck when he was on the field for us...just his legs were gone.

 

[ALinda]

Go.

Brad Parker is in there, along with the guy they promoted from the Penal League in 2004 when they couldn't afford to spend the salary cap. Shane Winters.

Why have this negativity an hour after a win. Life's too short - just enjoy the win.

 

[MadMarcus]

Shayne Hayne

 

[MissKate]

Got to throw brett kimmorley in there also