Lyon as good as Inglis

[Napper]

According to mortimer and Krillich

Theyre wrong. He is twice as good.

http://dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/steve-mortimer-and-max-krillich-rate-manly-captain-jamie-lyon-the-best-centre-in-the-game/story-e6frexnr-1226448224088

 

[Captain Moondog]

He's got a better football brain. Actually, I'm just listening to the Inglis interview on the Footy Show, he's got a better brain, fullstop

 

[susan]

different players,both great.

in a gf when the whips are cracking i'll cop Jamie every time and that is no disrespect to GI.

 

[Av8r]

Lyon's brilliant. Inglis can barely string a sentence together on the footy show this morning.

 

[Phantar]

'Even with Geoff Toovey as coach' according to Turvey. Not sure if that was an intentional backhander or what.

 

[wombatgc]

Anyone think jamie has a future as a ventriloquist?
...he speaks like his jaws been wired.

 

[Chip and Chase]

Inglis on the footy show is a deadset mumbleathon. It's a laugh a minute watching him trying to tackle any word over two syllables.

In terms of football ability, I'd say that Inglis is probably the more versatile of the two, but Killer is by far much more consistent and ALWAYS gives 100%. I know who I'd want beside me in the trenches, Killer delivers everytime.

 

[BOZO]

Lyons and Inglis are both brilliant but Lyons is better because he is quicker between the ears

 

[manlyfan76]

Ingliss has a better attack... Off the field.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Different types of players so hard to compare, Matai is more the Inglis style of centre than Lyon

Jamie is a skill and football smarts style, Inglis was a power style

 

[Phantar]

Lyons and Inglis are both brilliant but Lyons is better because he is quicker between the ears

Yeah Lyons was great, but he retired from the NRL in 1999.

 

[BOZO]

Lyons and Inglis are both brilliant but Lyons is better because he is quicker between the ears

Yeah Lyons was great, but he retired from the NRL in 1999.

You got me Phantar lol

 

[Phantar]

No problems Boze.

 

[Top End Eagle]

Lyon was destroyed by Inglis in 07 GF and in a SOO match around 2008. I personally think he is more consistent and wouldn't swap him for any player in the comp, in terms of where he plays or how he plays. He has been our best player since BK left bar none.

To argue against Inglis on his performance on the Sunday Footy Show is stupid. Jamie isn't the most eloquent of players and I don't care who is or isn't made for post footy media work. Those of you who could only find Inglis's performance on the TV this morning to knock him I am sure are wonderful public speakers and exemplary athletes - or you are just keyboard hero's who act like all true knobs I have ever known - take something that they are better or more comfortable with than a perceived threat and use that to elevate themselves.


I would have Jamie Lyon over Inglis every day of the week but I am picking a bloke to play football not host Toastmasters. Some of the comments on here baffle me. It's like a gaggle of geese most of the time.

 

[bob dylan]

Both superstars.

Main difference one plays for Manly.

and

The other plays for money and is a salary cap cheat.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Lyon was destroyed by Inglis in 07 GF and in a SOO match around 2008. I personally think he is more consistent and wouldn't swap him for any player in the comp, in terms of where he plays or how he plays. He has been our best player since BK left bar none.

To argue against Inglis on his performance on the Sunday Footy Show is stupid. Jamie isn't the most eloquent of players and I don't care who is or isn't made for post footy media work. Those of you who could only find Inglis's performance on the TV this morning to knock him I am sure are wonderful public speakers and exemplary athletes - or you are just keyboard hero's who act like all true knobs I have ever known - take something that they are better or more comfortable with than a perceived threat and use that to elevate themselves.


I would have Jamie Lyon over Inglis every day of the week but I am picking a bloke to play football not host Toastmasters. Some of the comments on here baffle me. It's like a gaggle of geese most of the time.

Inglis played 5/8 in the 2007 GF

 

[Jonesyv2]

Lyon has 2 Premierships, a Challenge cup and ESL championship, Inglis has ??

 

[Phantar]

Ingliss has a better attack... Off the field.

Yes, didn't see a 'wifebasher' singlet in his new GI clothing range. I thought that might have been appropriate.

 

[Captain Moondog]

To argue against Inglis on his performance on the Sunday Footy Show is stupid. Jamie isn't the most eloquent of players and I don't care who is or isn't made for post footy media work. Those of you who could only find Inglis's performance on the TV this morning to knock him I am sure are wonderful public speakers and exemplary athletes - or you are just keyboard hero's who act like all true knobs I have ever known - take something that they are better or more comfortable with than a perceived threat and use that to elevate themselves.

Or maybe everybody is entitled to their own opinion, regardless of how many knobs they've known.

 

[eagles2win]

Lyon has 2 Premierships, a Challenge cup and ESL championship, Inglis has ??

And two wcc's from memory
Saints
And
Manly

---

For those bad mouthing Inglis, I actually find DCE ordinary commentating.
But love Anasta, Ennis and Rose doing it.