Coffee this morning with a Doggies fan and a Parra supporter when Josh Reynolds came up. "What a grub' I said "what about Matai they chorused" like mindless gibberers. "Are you telling me that if Matai turned up at Belmore or Parra you wouldn't put him straight into your team" I asked "of course we would" they agreed. "And what if Josh Reynolds turned up at Brookie" the poor deluded doggie asked. "What, in place of Foran,"That's not a fair comparison" I said "one is a despicable dirty grub and the others a Kiwi genius" I replied. It's a fact, they all hate Matai, but would take him in a heartbeat, and as the doggie fan ended up saying "I can understand why Manly fans love him" If Cam Smith became available would you welcome him to Manly?