Idris

[Kiwi Eagle]

That clipping of Nighingales legs was one of the most dangerous and sickening things I have seen on the league field for a while. Was seriously thinking broken neck possible upon 1st viewing

So what should happen too him ? I see he hasn't picked up a sighting or anything apparently which I find a bit hard to believe. It might not have been deliberate, but neither are all of the spear tackles we see blokes missing weeks for

 

[eagles2win]

3 weeks minimum (and that's cause he's got a clean record). If it was someone like Morely 6 weeks

 

[chris_niko]

I noticed one particular replay last night that showed him raise his elbow and clip him that forced him to flip on his head/neck. Not much got mentioned about the elbow so i dont think he'll get suspended. In my opinion though, 3 weeks minimum

 

[Garts]

He has a cool hairdo = 0 weeks.

 

[ayjay007]

He's not a Manly player..ticker-tape parade and salary cap exclusion!

 

[Chip and Chase]

I thought they said it was put on report during the telecast. However I'm not convinced there was a lot of intention on Idris's part. I think he was chasing through on the ball and got himself in an awkward position once Nightingale got up above him. He actually looked like he tried to minimise the contact. It looked ugly but I think it was an accident.

 

[Masked Eagle]

I thought they said it was put on report during the telecast. However I'm not convinced there was a lot of intention on Idris's part. I think he was chasing through on the ball and got himself in an awkward position once Nightingale got up above him. He actually looked like he tried to minimise the contact. It looked ugly but I think it was an accident.

Same here. He didn't place a lot of contact on him either, just got him at the right spot (or wrong spot as the case maybe) and Nightingales momentum took care of the rest.

 

[eagles2win]

I thought they said it was put on report during the telecast. However I'm not convinced there was a lot of intention on Idris's part. I think he was chasing through on the ball and got himself in an awkward position once Nightingale got up above him. He actually looked like he tried to minimise the contact. It looked ugly but I think it was an accident.

Still had time to pull out though mate

 

[jjai]

puppy fat chubby boi.. i dont even know why he is rated .. takes him 30 meters to wind up by then he is smashed & they make him winger slowest one going,,,

but i will give him credit tends to use his big frame better in situations than Trex does.. espically close to line .. can jump better too, but he aint no superstar..

 

[eagles2win]

puppy fat chubby boi.. i dont even know why he is rated .. takes him 30 meters to wind up by then he is smashed & they make him winger slowest one going,,,

but i will give him credit tends to use his big frame better in situations than Trex does.. espically close to line .. can jump better too, but he aint no superstar..

Atleast TRex played test footy before him

 

[Jethro]

He has a cool hairdo = 0 weeks.

 

[Matabele]

puppy fat chubby boi.. i dont even know why he is rated .. takes him 30 meters to wind up by then he is smashed & they make him winger slowest one going,,,

but i will give him credit tends to use his big frame better in situations than Trex does.. espically close to line .. can jump better too, but he aint no superstar..

Careful about dissing T-Rex. Apparently he's the best thing since sliced bread now. Pass the mustard.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Sounds a lot like the circumstances involved in a lot of spear tackles as well boys and they still get pinged

I thought they said it was put on report during the telecast. However I'm not convinced there was a lot of intention on Idris's part. I think he was chasing through on the ball and got himself in an awkward position once Nightingale got up above him. He actually looked like he tried to minimise the contact. It looked ugly but I think it was an accident.

Same here. He didn't place a lot of contact on him either, just got him at the right spot (or wrong spot as the case maybe) and Nightingales momentum took care of the rest.

 

[jjai]

puppy fat chubby boi.. i dont even know why he is rated .. takes him 30 meters to wind up by then he is smashed & they make him winger slowest one going,,,

but i will give him credit tends to use his big frame better in situations than Trex does.. espically close to line .. can jump better too, but he aint no superstar..

Careful about dissing T-Rex. Apparently he's the best thing since sliced bread now. Pass the mustard.

i wasn`t dissing wish he would step up,, cant diss stats..

 

[Masked Eagle]

Sounds a lot like the circumstances involved in a lot of spear tackles as well boys and they still get pinged

I thought they said it was put on report during the telecast. However I'm not convinced there was a lot of intention on Idris's part. I think he was chasing through on the ball and got himself in an awkward position once Nightingale got up above him. He actually looked like he tried to minimise the contact. It looked ugly but I think it was an accident.

Same here. He didn't place a lot of contact on him either, just got him at the right spot (or wrong spot as the case maybe) and Nightingales momentum took care of the rest.

True dat. He might indeed face a charge but if he did I'd imagine it would be the lowest you could get.

Actually, thinking about it now. As it was an international game I'm not even sure if the same penalty system applies. ie, ratings, levels, early guilty plea reductions etc. I'm guessing it won't go before the NRL match review, its probably already been reviewed by officials after the game and might have already been dismissed? Maybe?

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Yeah I think it has been dismissed I think I heard

I don't beleive there was any intent in it, but **** it ended up dangerous

 

[TokyoEagle]

It looked real bad. Not as bad as the tackler who got the knee to the face in the Waratahs Force game though.

 

[R3]

If that were a manly player no one here would be questioning it. Easy to be critical but there was nothing in it. Idris is a good clean (maybe not clean cut) young player. I wish him the best and hope he does NSW proud in the future.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Of course it would be questioned, it has to be when a bloke is clipped while 6 feet up in the air and comes close to landing on his head.

 

[ERNIE FOR NO7]

I thought they said it was put on report during the telecast. However I'm not convinced there was a lot of intention on Idris's part. I think he was chasing through on the ball and got himself in an awkward position once Nightingale got up above him. He actually looked like he tried to minimise the contact. It looked ugly but I think it was an accident.

that is my view also