Foul Play

[COMMANDER]

Serial tripper Josh Renolds was sent to the bin for impeding Soward in a kick chase scenario yesterday which is good

You'd have to wonder why Thurston was not binned for his effort late in the game in taking out a player while making no attempt to defuse a high ball late in the Canberra game yesterday.

If he is not on the field he doesn't get the chance to kick a field goal to win. Very poor that be wasn't binned.

 

[ssteacup]

To me that send off of Reynolds was an awful decision. Lets put it this way, if it was one of our players who got ten for that I would be raging.

 

[Sheikheagle]

To me that send off of Reynolds was an awful decision. Lets put it this way, if it was one of our players who got ten for that I would be raging.

Reynolds is a grub but he was hard done by in that play

 

[blacktown eagle]

Reynolds is a grub but he was hard done by in that play

How was he hard done by? Its a professional foul. Its the rules and as long as the refs are consistent if it happened to us I'd be okay with that.

 

[HappilyManly]

How was he hard done by? Its a professional foul. Its the rules and as long as the refs are consistent if it happened to us I'd be okay with that.

Grubby was hard done by as it was Sowards heel that connected with his knee, not his hands touching Soward.
Completey accidental

 

[torana355]

The grubs previous indiscretions are now catching up with him. He was hard done by yesterday.

 

[blacktown eagle]

Grubby was hard done by as it was Sowards heel that connected with his knee, not his hands touching Soward.
Completey accidental

Sorry, didn't actually see the incident thanks for clarifying things

 

[mjb136]

JT should have been binned.

But given the referees are actually a joke, I'm not surprised he wasn't.

The inconsistentcy of refereeing is a massive blight on the game.

Jared Maxwell is my case in point.

 

[KOMORI]

JT wasn't binned because the refs were doing everything in their power to get the cows home.. Ridiculous run of penalties was what got the cows anywhere near being in a position to kick a field goal..

 

[globaleagle]

I'm still a bit surprised not much was made of tapau knocking dce over (after dce let a kick off bounce.)

Just ran past and drilled him in the shoulder...knocked him over etc.

But nothing.

I think HM mentioned and that's all I could find ...anywhere!

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Malcolm Knox wrote a funny article on SOO grubs yesterday. The attached cartoon is worth a look alone.

 

[globaleagle]

 

[Baz]

JT wasn't sinbinned, but neither was Blake Austin for a similarly professional foul at the end of the first half on Gavin Cooper. The refs were consistent with both teams and I was happy with that.

 

[sheridanstand78]

To me that send off of Reynolds was an awful decision. Lets put it this way, if it was one of our players who got ten for that I would be raging.

I think it was an accident. Soward has form for diving too so I think the refs should have given a penalty for the collision but that would be enough, Thurston should have been binned for 10, no attempt to take the ball and every intention of taking the man out.