Cows 2005 try vs Manly 2021 try. Who wins?

[Brissie Kid]

Cows 2005 try at Brookie.

Manly 2021 try at T'ville.

 

[Uk eagle]

I think you've picked the wrong place if you wanted a seriously balanced view though!

 

[castle eagle]

that try by the cows would have to be the worst effort of defence i can remember from beaver, but the try from last year s#!ts all over it!

 

[Shoe1]

2005 was a major disappointment, I saw it unfolding and couldn’t believe it.

 

[NYEagle]

Both great tries but Vossys call gets the Manly one over the line.

NYEagle

 

[Mal Cochrane]

that try by the cows would have to be the worst effort of defence i can remember from beaver, but the try from last year s#!ts all over it!

Around that time wasn't a good time for Beaver. His form was way down where I was questioning if he was done.
History will now prove otherwise

 

[voicefromthehill]

Both awesome tries, but comparatively the Cows try was just fast buggers from a kick return. Ours was attack to defence to attack...
The easy option for Garrick was to run dead, but no he said "not tonight Josephine" (A completely misapplied saying but it felt good here). With swerve and verve he left the Cows in his wake, then our oft maligned captain took up the reins and out sprinted another saunter of cowboys - only to put it on the toe for our Tom pick it up and then go all Nureyev and pirouette around the rest and score

 

[madmax]

I've seen plenty of similar trys to the Cows but Manly 2021 is a no brainer & much better than the Cows.

 

[40 nil]

In the context of the game, Williams' try was more important than Turbo's. From memory, it was a major factor in the Cowboys' win, whereas the game was already done & dusted when Turbo scored. Also, Bowen evaded two defenders before passing to Williams and then Williams shrugged off Snake on his way to the line.

 

[Brissie Kid]

In the context of the game, Williams' try was more important than Turbo's. From memory, it was a major factor in the Cowboys' win, whereas the game was already done & dusted when Turbo scored. Also, Bowen evaded two defenders before passing to Williams and then Williams shrugged off Snake on his way to the line.

Yep, that loss was so disappointing at the time. Think that was the same game the referee let the Cows kick off & recover the ball while Manly's goal kicker was still running back across the halfway line. Chris Hicks i think.

EDIT: yep, it was this game. If this doesn't make you angry as Manly fan vs Cows... We had this game won. Go to 21 mins.

 

[Brissie Kid]

Manly won this entirely fair and independent poll of league experts by a thumping 18-2 victory.