Coalt Train to miss 5 weeks

and good luck to us

 

Fat touchie

 

It deserved 5 weeks. It was a shocker!

 

Geez I didnt think it was any worse than Ukelele's.

 

Just watched it again and it looked a lot worse in the game. It wasn't that bad.

 

5 weeks, gees, he'll come back at 150 kilos if he hangs out with Russell during the stint on the sidelines

 

NO doubt deserved min 4 weeks but how the f#*k does Uate get off with his text book spear - Matai would have copped 6 for that imo.

 

No difference between Uate's tackle & Taylor's. Both real bad.
One week for Uate was just another in the long line of totally ludicrous SOO-related judiciary decisions. This time Meninga had already flagged that Taylor was excess to needs for game 3.

 

Totally agree the Qlders have a right to be peaved for lack of consistency. Uate's tackle should have been a 4 weeker and so should have taylors.

 

qldlers should have lost half a dozen players in the last 5 years but didnt so they cant cry foul

 

I think Sutton had more to do with the way the tackle ended up. 5 weeks for Taylor is a bit harsh and I don't even like Souths or QLD.

 

I think it's very harsh. I thought only Matai ever gets five weeks. Good for us though. I've just had a look at our run home and it's pretty tough.

 

The thing is by the time you add loading, carryover points and extra for fighting the charge it was probably only 3 weeks for Joe average which is reasonable for the tackle but got extended to five. Sucked in to him, he should have just copped 4.

 

whats a "coalt" train?

 

Won't have to look at his barge a**e every time his shorts come down!

 

you dont get extra for fighting it, you just get a reduction for bending over and taking it

 

You beauty, 5 weeks for the train , and high fives for the Sea eagles.