Search results
-
No Heart
The game But how the F do you not aim up defensively from that point if you want to be a true contender?- maxta
- Post #39
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
No Heart
Correct me Miss school teacher - fact is it was terrible to not go on with that momentum- maxta
- Post #38
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
No Heart
We level at 14 all Fall away from there ??? EVERY other team coming from behind has gone on to Win .... except Manly Just kind of clocked off Boo me Boo them But absolutely terrible- maxta
- Thread
- Replies: 67
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
-
Tallyn Da Silva
Good points and much I agree with In fact in many ways the saying about "not up to 1st grade " in a way doesn't make sense, but can from a different view....as we are talking about players who have already played 1st grade right ?? But here's the point I try make How good was BK ? Absolute gun...- maxta
- Post #58
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Tallyn Da Silva
In literal terms so do I. However when a player who has busted his guts and played out of position and is on the verge of medical retirement, it becomes reality. Would be 3rd option at dummy half at best at majority of NRL clubs and no insult to a soldier of a player, but I believe that's where...- maxta
- Post #56
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Tallyn Da Silva
Fair comparison in many ways Kenny is certainly not flash or agile, but definitely more robust and is more of a threat than Croker....Croker is tough, but often still minced where Kenny is simply a stronger body- maxta
- Post #52
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Tallyn Da Silva
Some take it personally about Croker, but your 100% correct....it doesn't mean fans don't appreciate his heart, it's probably bigger than most, but the ability is unfortunately not u to what's needed as an NRL dummy half.- maxta
- Post #50
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
2026 recruitment & retention
To be fair, he was hot and cold....but all was forgiven the day he trampled over Slater....was a Monster at his Best !!- maxta
- Post #3,159
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Tallyn Da Silva
It's great you rate him a reasonable NRL standard and I don't think your "disrespecting" me, it's simply your opinion and your entitled to it. But I just want some clarity here on your opinion apart from "He can tackle". What other NRL sides would start Croker at hooker ? If he is available to...- maxta
- Post #43
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Tallyn Da Silva
The real problem is Croker was a junior 5/8, who Manly made into a dummy half after losing both API and Fainu, as Croker does add "utility" value....but the 9 is a very specialist position. Croker has enthusiasm and that is a MUST for any position, but lacks the key elements, making Manly...- maxta
- Post #33
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
David Fifita
100% grab him for that strike left edge if possible, most players bar Foran and Tino fall away on the Gold Coast....get him fresh and sprinkle some enthusiasm amd watch out - the old Fifita could well erupt.....be great for him and for Manly- maxta
- Post #5
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
The Daly Cherrygraph
Look - he has been gone for a while now ...destination was always Roosters, so would like to simply move forward in a Positive way. The reason Manly stuck so hard on the lures for Fogarty were all about this and now he is coming along gotta keep building in other area's where most needed. The...- maxta
- Post #12,488
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Pre-Game Manly V Sharks [Round 10, 2025]
Not bad selections at all....in fact apart from the argument of "IF" Navale should be there rather than Jazz which is a 50/50 type call for different reasons, it's a clear cut winner, with Jake T back to prop things look pretty good right now.- maxta
- Post #107
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Wiremu Greig ???
Need more quicks in the middle - I find Greig is a poor mans Sipley and follows the worst area of the Manly game today....mobility and agility through that middle....reasonable NSW cup depth and there are worse options, but I can't see it- maxta
- Post #6
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Pre-Game Manly V Sharks [Round 10, 2025]
Thx Bozo You are the Champion 🙌- maxta
- Post #40
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Pre-Game Manly V Sharks [Round 10, 2025]
Yep Definitely need more impact attack with speed and agility and dominance in that ruck with tempo - good call Bozo my man 🙌- maxta
- Post #38
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Pre-Game Manly V Sharks [Round 10, 2025]
76 your 1 of the best I don't see it season defining, but a Win would be Sweet and against a true contender- makes a statement I'll be very surprised if we don't win this game by 8-16 points- maxta
- Post #36
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
2026 Captain
Big Oka - will lift his energy, which will feed across the team...the Csptaincy will ensure involvement and the more you see him in a game, the chances of Manly Winning increase greatly....- maxta
- Post #34
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
-
Too much speed?
I think the Best out of yardage are players like To'o and Marzhew, stocky, not ultra fast but powerful and explosive....who can have late footwork but are more bulldozing close to the ground type wingers and I reckon 100% of NRL players would prefer stopping Tupou than these blokes, who are also...- maxta
- Post #18
- Forum: Rugby League Forum
