NYEagle
Bencher
The first three weeks I would have blamed it all on the season launch and the boardroom and off the field stuff.
Now I just think it is all about how the game has changed since last year and who we are missing and what junk has replaced them.
The game on the weekend was a great example. Penalties everywhere. The first 20 minutes was awful to watch, I was screaming at the television because Manly barely got on the field and there was the obligatory penalty and then suddenly 0-6 down. Great.
The game is so fast now that it is impossible for Manly to play their aggressive style in defence. The league is obsessed about potential grapple tackles and want to speed it up to a touch football game (ask Des). As a result, our agressive style of defense and lack of speed minus B Stewart are double whammies.
We have exactly the same starting forward pack as the grand final, and I think over the last 4 weeks they have played with exactly the same commitment. They just can't dominate the game if its touch football.
Then there is the backline - where we truly lack.
Robertson is not a fullback and can't break the line like B Stewart.
Bani is awful in defence, particularly his positioning.
Matai has put on weight since last year.
Bailey is the worst player to ever put on a Manly uniform. He is Orford without a kicking game. Can't break the line, timing absolutely terrible, and no skill whatsoever. Can we get over this experiment already?????
You then combine this with an Orford who never breaks the line and needs to be on a dominant team to play well.
Bottom line is our halves are awful and have no attacking potency.
At the end of the day, the club is going to have to lose Bailey and Bani and bring in Rodney and someone else from the Toyota Cup to give the backline some potency. In the meantime I'm going to cheer the Brisbanes, Saints, Canterburies and Tits to keep on winning so that they can make the threshold to sneak into the eight lower. At the end of the day if we get into the finals its just one extra game to play to get into the Grand Final.
Thats the long and short of it.
NYEagle
Now I just think it is all about how the game has changed since last year and who we are missing and what junk has replaced them.
The game on the weekend was a great example. Penalties everywhere. The first 20 minutes was awful to watch, I was screaming at the television because Manly barely got on the field and there was the obligatory penalty and then suddenly 0-6 down. Great.
The game is so fast now that it is impossible for Manly to play their aggressive style in defence. The league is obsessed about potential grapple tackles and want to speed it up to a touch football game (ask Des). As a result, our agressive style of defense and lack of speed minus B Stewart are double whammies.
We have exactly the same starting forward pack as the grand final, and I think over the last 4 weeks they have played with exactly the same commitment. They just can't dominate the game if its touch football.
Then there is the backline - where we truly lack.
Robertson is not a fullback and can't break the line like B Stewart.
Bani is awful in defence, particularly his positioning.
Matai has put on weight since last year.
Bailey is the worst player to ever put on a Manly uniform. He is Orford without a kicking game. Can't break the line, timing absolutely terrible, and no skill whatsoever. Can we get over this experiment already?????
You then combine this with an Orford who never breaks the line and needs to be on a dominant team to play well.
Bottom line is our halves are awful and have no attacking potency.
At the end of the day, the club is going to have to lose Bailey and Bani and bring in Rodney and someone else from the Toyota Cup to give the backline some potency. In the meantime I'm going to cheer the Brisbanes, Saints, Canterburies and Tits to keep on winning so that they can make the threshold to sneak into the eight lower. At the end of the day if we get into the finals its just one extra game to play to get into the Grand Final.
Thats the long and short of it.
NYEagle