My Ratings

[Nutzcraw]

Categories:

Excellent
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor

The categories I give isn't a reflection on what I give them out of 10.. the categories are determined as I say them while watching.

B. Stewart: 7/10 - Above Average.
M. Robbertson: 9/10 - Excellent.
Steve Bell: 7/10 - Above Average.
Clint Halden: 6/10 - Average.
Chris Hicks: 9/10 - Excellent.
Jamie Lyon: 9/10 - Excellent.
Matt Orford: 4/10 - Poor.
Jason King: 8/10 - Excellent.
M. Monaghan: 8/10 - Above Average.
Brent Kite: 9/10 - Excellent.
Anthony Watmough: 8/10 - Above Average.
Glenn Stewart: 7/10 - Average.
Luke Williamson: 6/10 Average.

Matt Ballin: 9/10 - Excellent.
George Rose: 6/10 - Average.
Mark Bryant: 4/10 - Poor.
Glenn Hall: 8/10 - Above Average.

 

[clontaago]

Id give Lyon a 10 Nutz

 

[Joey]

very generous of you to give orford a 4

 

[fLIP]

After watching the game again today I'd give Orford a 5. He wasn't as bad as we originally thought.

Also, I'm a tad confused with your scoring Nutz.

If you have 5 categories and are breaking that into 10, logically wouldn't 2 points be poor and 4 points below average.

How come orford get poor?

Bryant had a better game than Rose. I would swap their scores. but give bryant 5

Not trying to change it too much but a few really bad reads from watmough lead to trys. I'd have him average and luke williamson spent about 70 mins on the bench. I'd give him a 4.