Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by Berkeley_Eagle, May 5, 2012.
Watch the Vid then vote
If t-Rex got 7 weeks ..... You must think this will get at least that. But Also take into account it goes to the match review committee. So maybe it will be 2 weeks
Not referring to manly bias. But the inconsistency
Was thinking exactly the same thing. Prior went in with intent, T-Rex did'nt. It reminded me of Les Boyds hit on Brohman in the 83 SOO. Boyd got 12 months. It's got to be worth more than 7 weeks. Prior is just lucky Thurston is'nt nursing a broken jaw.
Here s the Boyd v Brohman one
I actually thought it was a very awkward attempt at a shoulder that went wrong. Nothing like the other clip - which was deliberate.
I think they were both deliberate. You can see Prior watching Thurstons head as he raises his elbow. The main difference with the Boyd hit is that Brohman was moving at speed.
If Trex was worth 7 weeks, then Prior is worth 10. Anything less and the judiciary will be a laughing stock.
Worse look than any brawl at a match IMO, should be sat down for the season
Prior seemed to be pissed off after he stood on the sideline from the kickoff. Did you see him raise his arm up straight after that? Not sure who he connected with but Tamou became involved.
Not long after Jonathon Thurston head-butted his elbow.
It has to be more than what t-rex got. If Rex gets 7 because it could have injured his opponent then Prior has to get at least that. Thurston didn't play for the rest of the game whereas in the t-rex incident no-one was hurt if I remember correctly.
6 weeks minimum, deliberately attacking a guys head with an elbow and forearm like that is low and dangerous. It could actually kill someone. Had Thurston not been wearing head gear the hit would have been worse
Don't know how the grading system works but it has to be a very high grade. I think he has a clean record and might to argue clumsy not deliberate but I think must miss at least 6-8, surely? The fact thurston's head was a bit side-on probably brought the headgear into play, otherwise yes, the injury might have been Brohmanesque.
I would think Prior can expect 5-6 games on the sidelines for that cheap shot.
Depends if he has any 'Prior' offences
Points for intentional high tackle 950 pts +/- any priors
In Prior's defense, it WAS Thurston he hit.... And any judiciary incidents involving thurston are automatically -2 weeks...
I reckon the judiciary are like you have described prior. After getting knocked down a few times last year with challenges and down gradings they have hit the books in the off season, brushing up on technicalities, legal terms and precedents hoping to be a bill harrigan and become a central figure heads in the NRL
They wack a few outrageous charges like T rex, and get the suit dry cleaned hoping to get some overtime payments and some catering in phillip st, and everyone settles and accepts. The are champing at the bit to turn jury duty into a 3 week stay at the holiday inn. Someones gonna pay big time soon
Will it be prior. I suppose it depends on how the media rate the hit in the next couple of days. Paul kent should do a write up if he can spare the time, what with his life's work to bag manly fans, he is a busy guy and manly fans are everywhere. Its a full time gig
BE I'd be surprised if they didn't contest the 'intentional' aspect, if that was the charge.
Does the link show the only charges available?
Maybe Dangerous Conduct instead? Max is 700. Less discount for early pleaâ€¦ might miss about 5 weeks?
dont know what the charge was, was just assuming intentional
Separate names with a comma.