Ok here an arguement starter I'm sure I like most on here are two young to have seen fulton play and I know he is regarded by most as Manly's greatest player. I was thinking who better since then and I find it hard to Seperate cliffy and brett. Both played origin and test footy, both have won 2 comps both have been essential parts of sides they played in. Lyons suffers from stats not being kept for try assists I'm certain if they were he would be the record holder while brett is still an outside chance of beating ken irvines try scoring record if he plays on past 2016. While both along with beaver are my favourite manly players ever I think Brett edges cliff out because defensively he is stronger and Is more consistent than napper. What do you blokes think or am I missing someone else who should be there.