This debate grows legs more when it involves a Seaeagles player but fact is, it happens at every club. Personally a massive fan of loyalty & certain players like the Beaver is living proof this still exists. Thing is, Beaver could have collected more coin elsewhere, but these offers came when he was an established superstar on good money already & had the smarts to realise staying at the 1 powerful club was a great investment for his future off the field.....1 club star players are held in high esteem & are a rare breed respected even by opposition fans. Then we look at young Knight - imo a future gun, but unproven at NRL level. Roosters have got in under the guard & appear to have offered far bigger money in what seems to be almost a replicated Warea - Hargreaves case....... case closed - well noone here knows 100%. Personally think its tough to judge the kid on this, ANY youngster in the modern game would have doors open to massive overs from other clubs & while we talk loyalty.....there is a business side in this case. Looking in from the outside I think "Hey , Hold on Liam - the grass may look greener today, but both your footy future & financial situation are better long term where you already are" Whatever the outcome in this case there is a bigger picture for mine - honesty & ethics. My favourite player back in the day, Ron Gibbs jumped ship to Gold Coast & I was a shattered kid. Almost angry, thinking about that loyalty card, but Gibbs turned me with his amazing couragous footy on the field showing he was 100% commited to Manly & in my eyes, maintained his Manly legend status. If anything he was a man possessed, lifting his intensity somehow & went out a winner. Point is, rather than bluff the fans on a players future, show some integrity & don't pretend its still some ongoing decision for the entire season, misleading the fans & team mates. The young players are not at fault, keep in mind they are media puppets repeating advice from managers, family ect....IF knight or ANY player is leaving, far more respect is earned by honesty & then simply getting on with the job of playing good footy till its time to move on.