1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Grand final player ratings

Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by Berkeley_Eagle, Oct 9, 2008.

  1. Berkeley_Eagle

    Berkeley_Eagle Current Status: 24/7 Manly Fan 2016 Tipping Competitor

    15,995
    1,849
    Ratings:
    +2,115 / 14
    Grand final player ratings

    http://blogs.smh.com.au/sinbin/archives/2008/10/grand_final_player_ratings_1.html


    The 34 players score a rating out of 10 from the Herald's writers Jamie Pandaram and Andrew Stevenson.
    Manly Sea Eagles

    1 BRETT STEWART - 7.5
    No man should wish on their worst enemy having to catch the Greg Inglis bomb that Stewart faced. By the time it had come down most fans had gone for a beer run and returned to their seats. The fullback was nowhere near it, got smashed into the goalpost but bounced back.

    2 MICHAEL ROBERTSON - 8.5
    How he managed to keep his foot above the white-painted sideline grass for his first-half try will remain one of the great grand final mysteries. Defended the high ball with aplomb apart from one shocker. His second try was magic, his third tragic - for Melbourne.

    3 STEVEN BELL - 7
    Always squeezing himself out of tackles, Bell never let anyone get out of his. Fittingly for a player who has maintained such high quality over so many years, he bowed out of the NRL with a try.

    4 STEVE MATAI - 7
    No surprises with his game. Raced in to smash anything wearing purple, made some strong charges from dummy-half and when the forwards were tired. Also did the one job most required of him: block Folau's runs for the high ball.

    5 DAVID WILLIAMS - 7
    "Wolfie" played like it was full moon. Defended stoutly, ran without fear and there was only one thing to say after his try: "Ooowwwwwwwwww!". Might make the same noise if he gets a Kangaroos call-up.

    6 JAMIE LYON - 8
    Looking more and more like the representative five-eighth that he apparently doesn't want to be - unless he can represent Wee Waa. To Manly's benefit, Lyon has dedicated his energy to the club cause, and his improvement at five-eighth has allowed his captain to shine.

    7 MATT ORFORD (c) - 8.5
    Ran the show like a Dally M medallist should. After smashing the ball out of Kaufusi's arms, he called the play that resulted in the next try. General passing and kicking game - flawless. What pressure? If there were a monkey on his back, it is now saying: "Pray for Mojo".

    8 BRENT KITE - 9
    Huge effort from the player good enough for Australia but not NSW. Never short of a hit-up, and if ever a prop deserved a grand final try it was him. The stretch, putdown and celebration topped off a wonderful year. Wonder if Bellamy wants him now?

    9 MATT BALLIN - 7
    Kicked it off with a sneaky try from close range, Ballin has half the aura of Michael Monaghan but now wears a premiership ring when most said Manly were doomed without the former hooker-halfback. Ballin's personal training business should skyrocket after this.

    10 JOSH PERRY - 7.5
    Big and strong, Perry won a premiership with Newcastle in 2001 and backed up with another powerful performance, carting the ball up to the line - and often through it. No rushes of blood that have proved so costly in the past.

    11 ANTHONY WATMOUGH - 8.5
    Strong running, big defence. The horrors of last year's decider were smashed into oblivion by a sledgehammer performance.

    12 GLENN HALL - 7.5
    Smiled his way out of the pre-game huddle. Smiles grew wider as he played a big role in building the Sea Eagles' forward platform. By the way, did you see the smile as he rocketed onto the ball on the way to Bell's try?

    13 GLENN STEWART - 8
    Tackled himself to utter exhaustion, didn't bother conserving energy for his trademark line breaks, just rolled up the sleeves and did what was necessary to win.

    14 HEATH L'ESTRANGE - 6
    Polished display from the nippy dummy-half. Kept the pressure on the Storm when he replaced Ballin.

    15 MARK BRYANT - 7
    One of the spak-filler boys coming off the bench, he didn't let the tempo slip at all in a mistake-free performance. There mightn't be many who remember all of his career; Bryant won't forget his 100th game however.

    16 JASON KING - 7
    First prop off the bench, King ran with gusto and was heavily involved in defence.

    17 STEVE MENZIES - 8
    Simply . . . the best. Livened up the team when injected after 20 minutes. Kept threatening the defence and was fittingly rewarded with one final try. Is that really the end of Beaver fever?
    Melbourne Storm
    1 BILLY SLATER - 6 Caught bombs that would have made others run in the opposite direction. Problem was, once he had the ball, all he could see were angry Manly dudes ready to chop him down.

    2 STEVE TURNER - 5
    Couldn't get into the game. He could only stretch out and watch as Robertson got his hat-trick. After being exposed in Origin, Turner again looked short of the goods on the big stage. Three tries to his opposite man says that in spades.

    3 MATT GEYER - 5
    A sad farewell for the man who has played for so long that an old adversary like Nathan Brown has been able to start and end a coaching career while "Boofa" kept playing. Maybe last year would have been a better time to quit.

    4 ISRAEL FOLAU - 8
    He was unstoppable early. Folau looked headed for the Clive Churchill Medal after 20 minutes but Manly used all their grit to shut him out. He was checked by Matai a few times as he went for bombs, and now, after experiencing every high in the game, he leaves Melbourne at his lowest point.

    5 ANTHONY QUINN - 5.5
    Couldn't replicate last year's try-scoring heroics - or tame the "Wolfman". At least it wasn't his side of the field that leaked tries like water out of a colander.

    6 GREG INGLIS - 5
    So many believed he would once again pull out a big game in a big game, but GI looked like an average Joe. With Manly defending like they did, the Storm were no chance if this guy didn't fire. And fire he didn't.

    7 COOPER CRONK (c) - 6
    Halfback on grand final night is not exactly the place to be when your team folds, your forwards don't go forward and your backs don't tackle. How was it Coops? "It sucked," he said succinctly.

    8 JEFF LIMA - 5
    One of the stars of last year's premiership victory, Lima was on the receiving end this time. Dropped the ball after a big tackle close to the line and failed to bend the defence as he usually does.

    9 RUSSELL AITKEN - 4
    Struggled during the tough stuff. Cam Smith's absence was always going to be telling, and though Aitken tried hard, he had too much to do for a player so inexperienced.

    10 BRETT WHITE - 4
    Needed to lead from the front. Last week he managed to smack Ben Ross in the head three times in one tackle - when he was running the ball. Could barely redden a toddler's bum last night.

    11 MICHAEL CROCKER - 8
    Did his best to intimidate the opposition but it seemed like Manly's forwards had all found their inner Crockers. Always a grand finalist; not often a winner.

    12 JEREMY SMITH - 7.5
    Stayed in Melbourne to win another premiership. Not quite. Still, kept on firing in a tireless performance - his last before he strips for the Dragons in 2009.

    13 DALLAS JOHNSON - 6
    A queer sort of game from Johnson. Threw himself around every leg he could see but also tried to get involved in passing the ball, which is not his go. Looked lost and isolated without Captain Cam and Ryan Hoffman.

    14 SCOTT ANDERSON - 4
    Bench forwards are supposed to come and make the opposition back-pedal; unfortunately, this one spent more time spinning the wheels on the training bike.

    15 ADAM BLAIR - 5
    Not his sort of game. Manly's dominance meant the Storm were searching for a squadron of tackle drones to try and close the game down. None were found.

    16 SIKA MANU - 6.5
    Inspired a bit of action, with those stocky legs providing some footwork and some much-needed spark for a sagging squad. But it was too little, too late.

    17 ANTONIO KAUFUSI - 7
    Annoyed the Manly players with his unrelenting defensive style. Made himself known to their attackers, and it was as appreciated as a fly in the mouth.

    Compiled by Jamie Pandaram and Andrew Stevenson
     
  2. eggson

    eggson Well-Known Member

    1,731
    144
    Ratings:
    +239 / 2
    They missed the 0. in front of Turner's rating.  Seriously, he is a fleshy speed bump at best.  Worst winger in the comp yet i reckon he'd have made the Roos team if Storm won. 

    My scores:

    1 BRETT STEWART - 40

    2 MICHAEL ROBERTSON - 40

    3 STEVEN BELL - 40

    4 STEVE MATAI - 40

    5 DAVID WILLIAMS - 40

    6 JAMIE LYON - 40

    7 MATT ORFORD (c) - 40

    8 BRENT KITE - 40

    9 MATT BALLIN - 40

    10 JOSH PERRY - 40

    11 ANTHONY WATMOUGH - 40

    12 GLENN HALL - 40

    13 GLENN STEWART - 40

    14 HEATH L'ESTRANGE - 40

    15 MARK BRYANT - 40

    16 JASON KING - 40

    17 STEVE MENZIES - 40

    Melbourne Storm
    1 BILLY SLATER - 0

    2 STEVE TURNER - 0

    3 MATT GEYER - 0

    4 ISRAEL FOLAU - 0

    5 ANTHONY QUINN - 0

    6 GREG INGLIS - 0

    7 COOPER CRONK (c) - 0

    8 JEFF LIMA - 0

    9 RUSSELL AITKEN - 0

    10 BRETT WHITE - 0

    11 MICHAEL CROCKER - 0

    12 JEREMY SMITH - 0

    13 DALLAS JOHNSON - 0

    14 SCOTT ANDERSON - 0

    15 ADAM BLAIR - 0

    16 SIKA MANU - 0

    17 ANTONIO KAUFUSI -0
    ;D
     
  3. Zep

    Zep Active Member

    1,692
    8
    Ratings:
    +8 / 0
    nice scores eggson! though slater did earn 0.5 after fly kicking crocker
     
  4. Kiwi Eagle

    Kiwi Eagle Moderator Staff Member 2016 Tipping Competitor

    14,488
    1,734
    Ratings:
    +2,425 / 31
    I read this at the airport on Monday, in disbelief with Crockers 8

    All his pre match talk about what he was actually going to do, and then what he produced after those statements, which was pretty much nothing, should not add up to an 8

    1 of the highlights for me was when he dropped the ball and Choc stood over him and gave it to him, loved it
     
  5. Canteen Worker

    Canteen Worker Well-Known Member 2016 Tipping Competitor

    13,234
    186
    Ratings:
    +212 / 5
    Crocker was very ordinary. Because he plays with passion some in the media love him.
     
  6. eggson

    eggson Well-Known Member

    1,731
    144
    Ratings:
    +239 / 2
    I know!  i was going to give Slater a half for kicking Crocker like Zep suggested, and also to Turner for providing easy access down his wing, but it's either a 40 or a 0!! 
    Man i'm loving this week.
     
  7. NYEagle

    NYEagle Well-Known Member

    1,385
    544
    Ratings:
    +1,154 / 69
    Egg - your rating point to a very careful and objective analysis of the players performances. Well done and thank you .  ;)
     
  8. Utility Player

    Utility Player Well-Known Member

    3,179
    256
    Lismore
    Ratings:
    +456 / 4
    They must give you 4 points for getting your boots on the right feet, only way White would have got his.
     

Share This Page