• We had an issue with background services between march 10th and 15th or there about. This meant the payment services were not linking to automatic upgrades. If you paid for premium membership and are still seeing ads please let me know and the email you used against PayPal and I cam manually verify and upgrade your account.

lismore_fan

Bencher
3- Foz
2 - DCE
1 - Glenn Stew

LEADERBOARD

21 J Thurston (NQL)

15 K Foran (MAN)

12 P Gallen (CRO)

12 B Slater (MEL)

12 C Smith (MEL)

12 B Marshall (WTI)

11 G Stewart (MAN)

11 C Sandow (SOU)

9 C Parker (BRI)

9 Cronk (MEL)

9 J Mullen (NEW)

9 M Gasnier (SGI)

8 B Barba (CBY)

8 B Creagh (SGI)

7 W Hopoate (MAN)

6 P Wallace (BRI)

6 J McCrone (CAN)

6 M Bowen (NQL)

6 F Mateo (NZL)

6 J Maloney (NZL)

6 L Burt (PAR)

6 L Walsh (PEN)

6 J Soward (SGI)

6 D Boyd (SGI)

6 R Farah (WTI)

5 J Hodges (BRI)

5 T Hodkinson (CBY)

5 L Bailey (GCT)

5 S Manu (MEL)

5 A Uate (NEW)

5 G Cooper (NQL)

5 J Hayne (PAR)

4 D Lockyer (BRI)

4 B Ferguson (CAN)

4 A Ryan (CBY)

4 F Pritchard (CBY)

4 M Hilder (NEW)

4 D Johnson (NQL)

4 M Scott (NQL)

4 S Mannering (NZL)

4 T Mannah (PAR)

4 N Hindmarsh (PAR)

4 L Lewis (PEN)

4 M Minichiello (GCT)

4 N Fien (SGI)

4 D Hunt (SGI)

4 B Scott (SGI)

4 S Kenny-Dowall (SYD)

4 M Pearce (SYD)

3 A Watmough
3 Cherry-Evans
2 Lyon
2 Matai
1 Buhrer
1 Brett Stew
 
thurston and kieran will clear away IMO.Easily best 2 playmakers in comp atm (not including locky as he will miss too many games to win it)and halves win it most years.

may come down to an injury and the way kieran plays it may be more likely he misses a couple.
 
lismore_fan said:
3- Foz
2 - DCE
1 - Glenn Stew

LEADERBOARD

21 J Thurston (NQL)

15 K Foran (MAN)

12 P Gallen (CRO)

12 B Slater (MEL)

12 C Smith (MEL)

12 B Marshall (WTI)

11 G Stewart (MAN)

11 C Sandow (SOU)

9 C Parker (BRI)

9 Cronk (MEL)

9 J Mullen (NEW)

9 M Gasnier (SGI)

8 B Barba (CBY)

8 B Creagh (SGI)

7 W Hopoate (MAN)

6 P Wallace (BRI)

6 J McCrone (CAN)

6 M Bowen (NQL)

6 F Mateo (NZL)

6 J Maloney (NZL)

6 L Burt (PAR)

6 L Walsh (PEN)

6 J Soward (SGI)

6 D Boyd (SGI)

6 R Farah (WTI)

5 J Hodges (BRI)

5 T Hodkinson (CBY)

5 L Bailey (GCT)

5 S Manu (MEL)

5 A Uate (NEW)

5 G Cooper (NQL)

5 J Hayne (PAR)

4 D Lockyer (BRI)

4 B Ferguson (CAN)

4 A Ryan (CBY)

4 F Pritchard (CBY)

4 M Hilder (NEW)

4 D Johnson (NQL)

4 M Scott (NQL)

4 S Mannering (NZL)

4 T Mannah (PAR)

4 N Hindmarsh (PAR)

4 L Lewis (PEN)

4 M Minichiello (GCT)

4 N Fien (SGI)

4 D Hunt (SGI)

4 B Scott (SGI)

4 S Kenny-Dowall (SYD)

4 M Pearce (SYD)

3 A Watmough
3 Cherry-Evans
2 Lyon
2 Matai
1 Buhrer
1 Brett Stew

Thurston needs to be taken out in a few weeks time at Brooky. I can seriously see Foran winning it then. Slater/Gallen/Smith will miss a few games with the origin to give Foran a greater lead.
Interesting though is that Gasnier and Creagh on 9 and Soward on 6. Fair way behind the leaders at the moment. Shows how had they will be to beat with an even playing roster.
 
eagleE said:
Thurston needs to be taken out in a few weeks time at Brooky. I can seriously see Foran winning it then.

He will be taken out - by the Qld selectors. Thurston won't be playing that match and neither will Scott.
 
Manly should cruise against NQ. No Scott, Tonga or Thurston leaves them without a lot of talent. Bowen is a great player but he really feeds off Thurston and should be fairly quiet in Thurston's absence. However, we could be without Watmough which is significant but we can win without him, NQ can't win without Thurston.
 
Bradza said:
eagleE said:
Thurston needs to be taken out in a few weeks time at Brooky. I can seriously see Foran winning it then.

He will be taken out - by the Qld selectors. Thurston won't be playing that match and neither will Scott.

Thanks for that Bradza. The next 2 games will cement our place or put doubts in the minds I think.
 
firechild said:
Manly should cruise against NQ. No Scott, Tonga or Thurston leaves them without a lot of talent. Bowen is a great player but he really feeds off Thurston and should be fairly quiet in Thurston's absence. However, we could be without Watmough which is significant but we can win without him, NQ can't win without Thurston.

Watmough's no chance.

Should've been the first forward picked. It's why NSW are ****.
 
Dally M Round 13

Sharks v Broncos  - Judge: Wally Lewis

3 B Hannant (BRI)
2 A Glenn (BRI)
1 C Parker (BRI)

Eels v Dragons - Judge: Andrew Johns

3 F Moimoi (PAR)
2 T Mannah (PAR)
1 D Hunt (SGI)

Titans v Panthers - Judge: Laurie Daley

3 P Civoniceva (PEN)
2 T Burns (PEN)
1 A Purtell (PEN)



Bulldogs v Sea Eagles - Judge: Greg Alexander
3 D Cherry-Evans (MAN)
2 J Lyon (MAN)
1 A Watmough (MAN)
 
Roosters v Warriors - Judge: Gary Belcher

3 J Friend (SYD)
2 J Ryles (SYD)
1 F Mateo (NZL))

Raiders v Cowboys - Judge: Gary Belcher

3 T Sims (NQL)
2 M Bowen (NQL)
1 S Fensom (CAN)

Rabbitohs v Storm - Judge: Andrew Johns

3 D Taylor (SOU)
2 C Smith (MEL)
1 R Hinchcliffe (MEL)


LEADERBOARD

21 J Thurston (NQL)
15 K Foran (MAN)
14 C Smith (MEL)
12 P Gallen (CRO)
12 B Slater (MEL)
12 B Marshall (WTI)
11 G Stewart (MAN)
11 C Sandow (SOU)
10 C Parker (BRI)
9 Cronk (MEL)
9 J Mullen (NEW)
9 M Gasnier (SGI)
8 B Barba (CBY)
8 M Bowen (NQL)
8 B Creagh (SGI)
7 W Hopoate (MAN)
7 F Mateo (NZL)
6 P Wallace (BRI)
6 B Hannant (BRI)
6 J McCrone (CAN)
6 D Cherry-Evans (MAN)
6 J Maloney (NZL)
6 L Burt (PAR)
6 T Mannah (PAR)
6 L Walsh (PEN)
6 P Civoniceva (PEN)
6 L Lewis (PEN)
6 J Soward (SGI)
6 D Boyd (SGI)
6 D Taylor (SOU)
6 R Farah (WTI)
5 J Hodges (BRI)
5 T Hodkinson (CBY)
5 L Bailey (GCT)
5 S Manu (MEL)
5 A Uate (NEW)
5 G Cooper (NQL)
5 T Sims (NQL)
5 J Hayne (PAR)
5 D Hunt (SGI)
5 J Friend (SYD)
4 D Lockyer (BRI)
4 B Ferguson (CAN)
4 S Fensom (CAN)
4 A Ryan (CBY)
4 F Pritchard (CBY)
4 J Lyon (MAN)
4 A Watmough (MAN)
4 M Hilder (NEW)
4 D Johnson (NQL)
4 M Scott (NQL)
4 S Mannering (NZL)
4 N Hindmarsh (PAR)
4 T Burns (PEN)
4 M Minichiello (GCT)
4 N Fien (SGI)
4 B Scott (SGI)
4 S Kenny-Dowall (SYD)
4 M Pearce (SYD)
3 C Heighington (WTI)
3 J Macguire (BRI)
3 J Picker (CAN)
3 J Idris (CBY)
3 A Tolman (CBY)
3 C Payne (CBY)
3 K Keating (CBY)
3 A Tupou (CRO)
3 S Mills (CRO)
3 a Harrison (GCT)
3 J Robson (PAR)
3 F Moimoi (PAR)
3 T Waterhouse (PEN)
3 M Gordon (PEN)
3 T Merrrin (SGI)
3 M Prior (SGI)
3 R Wesser (SOU)
3 J Sutton (SOU)
3 M Kennedy (SYD)
3 A Minichiello (SYD)
3 N Myles (SYD)
3 G Fisiahi  (NZL)
3 L Hohaia (NZL)
3 M Luck (NZL)
3 K Locke (NZL)
3 L Brown (NZL)
2 J Reed (BRI)
2 A Glenn (BRI)
2 J Hoffman (BRI)
2 D Tilse (CAN)
2 S Williams (CAN)
2 M Ennis (CBY)
2 J Morris (CBY)
2 J Smith (CRO)
2 K Snowden (CRO)
2 A Laffranchi (GCT)
2 G Bird (GCT)
2 D Mead (GCT)
2 S Matai (MAN)
2 K Proctor (MEL)
2 G Widdop (MEL)
2 A Blair (MEL)
2 C Houston (NEW)
2 Junior Sau  (NEW)
2 J Edwards (NEW)
2 Beau Henry (NEW)
2 K Gidley (NEW)
2 K Inu (NZL)
2 E Taylor (NZL)
2 B Matulino (NZL)
2  McGuire (PAR)
2 T Grant (PEN)
2 N Plum (PEN)
2 M Crocker (SOU)
2 A Gueraa (SYD) 
2 J Ryles (SYD)
2 J Nightingale (SGI)
2 K Stanley (SGI)
2 R Packer (NZL)
2 S Dwyer (WTI)
1 M Gillett (BRI)
1 N Kenny (BRI)
1 S Thaiday (BRI)
1 G Beale (BRI)
1 G Buttris (CAN)
1 S Turner (CBY)
1 N Gardner (CRO)
1 I Gordon (CRO)
1 R James (GCT)
1 N Friend (GCT)
1 J Buhrer (MAN)
1 B Stewart (MAN)
1 R Hinchclifffe (MEL)
1 W Naiqama (NEW)
1 A Graham (NQL)
1 L Coote (PEN)
1 A Purtell (PEN)
1 T Merrin (SGI)
1 D Young (SGI)
1 M Cooper (SGI)
1 D Farrell (SOU)
1 I Luke (SOU)
1 P MataUtia (SYD)
1 R Lui (WTI)
1 A Fifita (WTI)



 
 
Not sure why people put a lot of stock in this award. You could put a good case forward for arguing about 80% of the judges selections each week. Its like the Brownlow in the AFL, who cares about the Brownlow when you do nothing but bag the opinions of the people who give the points each week.
 

Members online

Team P W L PD Pts
6 5 1 20 12
6 4 2 53 10
5 4 1 23 10
6 4 2 48 8
6 4 2 28 8
5 3 2 14 8
7 4 3 -18 8
6 3 2 21 7
7 3 3 20 7
7 3 4 31 6
6 3 3 16 6
5 2 3 -15 6
7 3 4 -41 6
6 2 4 -5 4
6 2 4 -7 4
6 1 5 -102 4
5 0 5 -86 2
Back
Top Bottom