Buzz's top 50

[Rambo1987]

50 Wade Graham – Sharks
30%Underrated
40%Agree
30%Overrated


49 Issac Luke – Rabbitohs
59%Underrated
27%Agree
14%Overrated


48 Blake Ferguson – Raiders
9%Underrated
23%Agree
69%Overrated


47 Michael Ennis – Bulldogs
12%Underrated
24%Agree
64%Overrated


46 Dave Taylor – Titans
7%Underrated
33%Agree
59%Overrated


45 Sam Kasiano – Bulldogs
16%Underrated
52%Agree
32%Overrated


44 Josh Morris – Bulldogs
55%Underrated
38%Agree
7%Overrated


43 Josh Reynolds – Bulldogs
21%Underrated
38%Agree
41%Overrated


42 Ryan Hoffman – Storm
20%Underrated
49%Agree
31%Overrated


41 Adam Reynolds – Rabbitohs
26%Underrated
58%Agree
16%Overrated


40 Tariq Sims – Cowboys
21%Underrated
53%Agree
27%Overrated


39 Luke Lewis – Sharks
46%Underrated
36%Agree
18%Overrated


38 Michael Jennings – Roosters
9%Underrated
27%Agree
64%Overrated


37 Daly Cherry Evans – Sea Eagles
19%Underrated
56%Agree
25%Overrated


36 Mitchell Pearce – Roosters
7%Underrated
14%Agree
78%Overrated


35 Akuila Uate – Knights
11%Underrated
54%Agree
36%Overrated


34 Brett Morris – Dragons
24%Underrated
62%Agree
14%Overrated


33 Feleti Mateo – Warriors
18%Underrated
56%Agree
26%Overrated


32 Kurt Gidley – Knights
10%Underrated
22%Agree
68%Overrated


31 Matt Bowen – Cowboys
27%Underrated
63%Agree
9%Overrated


30 Tony Williams – Bulldogs
6%Underrated
33%Agree
61%Overrated


29 Brett Stewart – Sea Eagles
20%Underrated
46%Agree
34%Overrated


28 Justin Hodges – Broncos
15%Underrated
40%Agree
45%Overrated


27 Darius Boyd – Knights
4%Underrated
13%Agree
83%Overrated


26 David Shillington – Raiders
9%Underrated
35%Agree
56%Overrated

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/nrl-top-50

 

[susan]

If bullet is the 29th best player in the comp then that will do me.Shillington is three spots better than him!please.

Nice overrated percentage for Rex!

 

[Captain Moondog]

If bullet is the 29th best player in the comp then that will do me.Shillington is three spots better than him!please.

Nice overrated percentage for Rex!

And Darius Boyd rated above him too. I know who I'd rather have at fullback.

 

[Frogz]

Someone must have written this for Slothfield..He couldnt count past 12....6 fingers on each hand

 

[Rambo1987]

T-Rex had a horrible season last year and if he was still at Manly he wouldn't have been in the 50.

 

[firechild]

Looks like Buzz is way off the mark given how many people think that several players are overrated including She-Rex (63%), Jennings, (66%), Gidley (67%), Ferguson (68%), Pearce (78%) and Boyd (83%).

Expecting Foran, Gift, Choc and Killer all to feature tomorrow.

 

[bob dylan]

I am over disagreeing with this type of thing.

At the end of the day its his opinion. Rothfield has put it out there for comment, nothing more.

BTW Bryce Gibbs will be No 1

 

[Rambo1987]

Next 25

25 James Graham
7%Underrated
28%Agree
65%Overrated

24 Glenn Stewart – Sea Eagles
14%Underrated
50%Agree
36%Overrated

23 Jeremy Smith – Knights
11%Underrated
27%Agree
62%Overrated

22 Josh Dugan – Raiders
8%Underrated
29%Agree
63%Overrated

21 Kieran Foran – Sea Eagles
14%Underrated
55%Agree
32%Overrated

20 Sam Thaiday – Broncos
5%Underrated
40%Agree
55%Overrated

19 Anthony Watmough – Sea Eagles
7%Underrated
38%Agree
54%Overrated

18 Greg Bird – Titans
13%Underrated
60%Agree
27%Overrated

17 Nate Myles – Titans
12%Underrated
54%Agree
35%Overrated

16 Todd Carney – Sharks
8%Underrated
37%Agree
55%Overrated

15 Matt Scott – Cowboys
15%Underrated
75%Agree
11%Overrated

14 James Tamou – Cowboys
11%Underrated
73%Agree
16%Overrated

13 Sam Burgess – Rabbitohs
22%Underrated
58%Agree
20%Overrated

12 Jamie Lyon – Sea Eagles
22%Underrated
41%Agree
37%Overrated

11 Benji Marshall – Tigers
10%Underrated
30%Agree
60%Overrated

10 Robbie Farah – Tigers
14%Underrated
33%Agree
53%Overrated

9 Paul Gallen – Sharks
34%Underrated
52%Agree
14%Overrated

8 Jarryd Hayne – Eels
12%Underrated
22%Agree
66%Overrated

7 Sonny Bill Williams – Roosters
7%Underrated
8%Agree
85%Overrated

6 Cooper Cronk – Storm
22%Underrated
63%Agree
15%Overrated

5 Ben Barba – Bulldogs
9%Underrated
47%Agree
44%Overrated

4 Greg Inglis – Rabbitohs
21%Underrated
66%Agree
12%Overrated

3 Billy Slater – Storm
8%Underrated
74%Agree
18%Overrated

2 Johnathan Thurston – Cowboys
11%Underrated
77%Agree
12%Overrated

1 Cameron Smith – Storm
3%Underrated
66%Agree
31%Overrated

 

[bob dylan]

I like his list.

SBW and Carney are a bit over stated but that's just my opinion.

 

[Masked Eagle]

I actually think he hasn't done too bad a job. I'd definitely have a different 50 for sure, but so would everyone else. Also like the idea of voting underrated, agree or overrated.

Althought I'm not sure of what the 3% of people thinking that Cameron Smith is underrated are smoking?

 

[manlyfan76]

Next weeks list;
Buzz top 50: c0(k$ he'd like $m0k3!

 

[Captain Moondog]

I actually think he hasn't done too bad a job. I'd definitely have a different 50 for sure, but so would everyone else. Also like the idea of voting underrated, agree or overrated.

Althought I'm not sure of what the 3% of people thinking that Cameron Smith is underrated are smoking?

Probably the same stuff the 37% of people who reckon Jamie is overrated are smoking.

 

[Chip and Chase]

Looks like $BW takes out most overrated award - 85%

 

[Masked Eagle]

I actually think he hasn't done too bad a job. I'd definitely have a different 50 for sure, but so would everyone else. Also like the idea of voting underrated, agree or overrated.

Althought I'm not sure of what the 3% of people thinking that Cameron Smith is underrated are smoking?

Probably the same stuff the 37% of people who reckon Jamie is overrated are smoking.

I can live with people not agreeing with someones rank, but Cameron Smith has been ranked NUMBER 1, yet 3% of respondents have said he should be ranked higher ...

 

[MWSE]

I actually think he hasn't done too bad a job. I'd definitely have a different 50 for sure, but so would everyone else. Also like the idea of voting underrated, agree or overrated.

Althought I'm not sure of what the 3% of people thinking that Cameron Smith is underrated are smoking?

Probably the same stuff the 37% of people who reckon Jamie is overrated are smoking.

I can live with people not agreeing with someones rank, but Cameron Smith has been ranked NUMBER 1, yet 3% of respondents have said he should be ranked higher ...

QLD mathematics mate.

 

[MadMarcus]

I actually think he hasn't done too bad a job. I'd definitely have a different 50 for sure, but so would everyone else. Also like the idea of voting underrated, agree or overrated.

Althought I'm not sure of what the 3% of people thinking that Cameron Smith is underrated are smoking?

Probably the same stuff the 37% of people who reckon Jamie is overrated are smoking.

I can live with people not agreeing with someones rank, but Cameron Smith has been ranked NUMBER 1, yet 3% of respondents have said he should be ranked higher ...

Maybe they are trying to say that since he has 2 contracts he should have 2 ratings? By only giving him 1 rating you are underrating him.

 

[Rambo1987]

I actually think he hasn't done too bad a job. I'd definitely have a different 50 for sure, but so would everyone else. Also like the idea of voting underrated, agree or overrated.

Althought I'm not sure of what the 3% of people thinking that Cameron Smith is underrated are smoking?

Probably the same stuff the 37% of people who reckon Jamie is overrated are smoking.

I can live with people not agreeing with someones rank, but Cameron Smith has been ranked NUMBER 1, yet 3% of respondents have said he should be ranked higher ...

Maybe they are trying to say that since he has 2 contracts he should have 2 ratings? By only giving him 1 rating you are underrating him.

Sounds like a Bulldogs theory